Discussion:
Eastman guitars - my take
(too old to reply)
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-03 17:45:05 UTC
Permalink
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having played
one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made guitar, when
you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for their efforts.

I'm not saying that Eastman guitars are the greatest guitars on the
planet... they may well be.

Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore guitar
that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I personally still
have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese, Korean, or Mexican
guitar.

Greg
Kevin Van Sant
2004-06-03 17:55:41 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having played
one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made guitar, when
you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?



_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar

http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.

Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-03 18:06:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.

Greg
Post by Kevin Van Sant
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar
http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.
Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
Kevin Van Sant
2004-06-03 18:16:33 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
No, but you did say the issue was knowing that the Chinese workers are
getting paid so little. So where do you draw the line? Shoes are ok
but guitars no? There's a higher margin on those shoes I'd bet. I
actually don't want to get into this discussion, and whatever you
choose is fine with me. It just seemed to me that you are groping for
reasons to dislike the Eastmans.
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar

http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.

Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
Jack Zucker
2004-06-03 19:53:54 UTC
Permalink
This reminds me a little of the ethical vegetarian debate.
--
web: http://www.jazguitar.net
Books: http://www.sheetsofsound.net
Endorsements: http://www.jackzucker.com/JazGuitar/endorsements.htm
Soundclips: http://www.soundclick.com/bands/2/jackzuckermusic.htm
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
No, but you did say the issue was knowing that the Chinese workers are
getting paid so little. So where do you draw the line? Shoes are ok
but guitars no? There's a higher margin on those shoes I'd bet. I
actually don't want to get into this discussion, and whatever you
choose is fine with me. It just seemed to me that you are groping for
reasons to dislike the Eastmans.
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar
http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.
Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
Kevin Van Sant
2004-06-03 19:54:03 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jack Zucker
This reminds me a little of the ethical vegetarian debate.
Exactly, which is why I don't want to get into it!
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar

http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.

Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
thom_j
2004-06-03 20:26:57 UTC
Permalink
Maybe they should Kathy Lee Gifford for more info? a curious tee'..
Post by Jack Zucker
This reminds me a little of the ethical vegetarian debate.
--
web: http://www.jazguitar.net
Books: http://www.sheetsofsound.net
Endorsements: http://www.jackzucker.com/JazGuitar/endorsements.htm
Soundclips: http://www.soundclick.com/bands/2/jackzuckermusic.htm
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
No, but you did say the issue was knowing that the Chinese workers are
getting paid so little. So where do you draw the line? Shoes are ok
but guitars no? There's a higher margin on those shoes I'd bet. I
actually don't want to get into this discussion, and whatever you
choose is fine with me. It just seemed to me that you are groping for
reasons to dislike the Eastmans.
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar
http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.
Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-03 20:06:20 UTC
Permalink
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
No, but you did say the issue was knowing that the Chinese workers are
getting paid so little. So where do you draw the line? Shoes are ok
but guitars no?
Yeah, when I pay $12-20 per pair at Payless, I'd say that's different
than chunking down 2 grand. And my shoes outlast my guitars.
Post by Kevin Van Sant
There's a higher margin on those shoes I'd bet. I
Well, at the prices I pay, they'd have to sell a whole lot more of 'em,
but I disagree when related to Eastman guitars.
Post by Kevin Van Sant
actually don't want to get into this discussion, and whatever you
choose is fine with me. It just seemed to me that you are groping for
reasons to dislike the Eastmans.
Yes, perhaps I am. Everyone else is trying to convince me how wrong I am
and most everybody here do not own an Eastman, which I find crazy
considering how hot everybody here seems to be for them.

Greg
Post by Kevin Van Sant
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar
http://www.kevinvansant.com
to buy my CDs, hear sound clips, see videos, and get more info.
Alternate site for recent soundclips
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/kevinvansant_music.htm
Max Leggett
2004-06-03 18:21:27 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
Well, "you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts", so I guess you're willingly exploiting Chinese labour.
It's ok to shaft Chinese workers for dress shoes, but not for guitars.
Got it.



=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
***@hotmail.com is a spam trap
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Greg M. Silverman
2004-06-03 18:24:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
Well, "you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts", so I guess you're willingly exploiting Chinese labour.
It's ok to shaft Chinese workers for dress shoes, but not for guitars.
Got it.
Also, US made could mean made in US territiories, which I believe could
be as sweat shop like as the next..
Sadly, it isn't as clear cut as one would really hope.

gms--
Pt
2004-06-03 21:18:58 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 13:24:16 -0500, "Greg M. Silverman"
Post by Greg M. Silverman
Also, US made could mean made in US territiories, which I believe could
be as sweat shop like as the next..
Sadly, it isn't as clear cut as one would really hope.
gms--
Shortly after WWII Japan started making cheap copies of everything.
They went so far to name one of their new industrial towns Usa.
Thus: Made in USA.

Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-03 20:08:31 UTC
Permalink
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
Well, "you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts", so I guess you're willingly exploiting Chinese labour.
It's ok to shaft Chinese workers for dress shoes, but not for guitars.
Got it.
I don't know what you pay, but I pay around $15 per pair. I own 2 pairs.
It's not like I have many choices for shoes like I do for guitars.

But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.

Greg
Post by Kevin Van Sant
=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Max Leggett
2004-06-03 20:10:11 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 20:08:31 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing
for
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
Well, "you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts", so I guess you're willingly exploiting Chinese labour.
It's ok to shaft Chinese workers for dress shoes, but not for guitars.
Got it.
I don't know what you pay, but I pay around $15 per pair. I own 2 pairs.
It's not like I have many choices for shoes like I do for guitars.
But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.
Evidently the best thing is for you to buy a Steve Howe signature 175.
That way you'll be assured of getting value for your money.




=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
***@hotmail.com is a spam trap
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 12:16:43 UTC
Permalink
Post by Max Leggett
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 20:08:31 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 18:06:46 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing
for
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Kevin Van Sant
Post by GregD/Oasysco
their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
My running shoes are US-made. Dress shoes are made in China and India.
But I'm not sure how that relates. Nowhere did I say I will not buy
Chinese made goods.
Well, "you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts", so I guess you're willingly exploiting Chinese labour.
It's ok to shaft Chinese workers for dress shoes, but not for guitars.
Got it.
I don't know what you pay, but I pay around $15 per pair. I own 2 pairs.
It's not like I have many choices for shoes like I do for guitars.
But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.
Evidently the best thing is for you to buy a Steve Howe signature 175.
That way you'll be assured of getting value for your money.
Ha! I knew I could convince you, Max! Now, yer thinkin'!

Greg
Post by Max Leggett
=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Formerly Sideways
2004-06-04 02:28:02 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
I don't know what you pay, but I pay around $15 per pair. I own 2 pairs.
It's not like I have many choices for shoes like I do for guitars.
What a bunch of hooey. Go to *any* mall and you can find shoes made
in Italy, Brazil and a bunch of other places. I own Italian-made and
Brazilian-made Bostonians, which are hardly rare, and the same shoes
are rebranded as Men's Wearhouse shoes.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.
You haven't played an Eastman, you don't really have any idea what
their workers really make, you aren't allowing for the fact that they
may be extremely well-paid by Chinese standards if not by our
standards, you don't know what the production or research and
development cost factors are, etc, etc, etc.

Therefore, you are completely talking through your hat when you say
that the workeres are "not getting a fair living wage," or that "the
price of Eastman guitars are over-flated." You don't really have any
flippin' idea.

And on top of it, you wear Chinese shoes?!? Oh brother.
thomas
2004-06-04 05:51:29 UTC
Permalink
Post by Formerly Sideways
Post by GregD/Oasysco
But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.
Ah, the good old labor theory of value. I did not know that you were
of the Marxian persuasion, Greg! My understanding is that Eastman
is owned by a Chinese family. Screwing your own people is just
capitalism at work, as Father Karl taught us. (How do you say
"Mr. Moneybags" in Chinese, I wonder?)
Post by Formerly Sideways
You haven't played an Eastman, you don't really have any idea what
their workers really make, you aren't allowing for the fact that they
may be extremely well-paid by Chinese standards if not by our
standards, you don't know what the production or research and
development cost factors are, etc, etc, etc.
Eastman claims that their workers make acround $200 a month, IIRC,
about twice the average wage in their area. And their rent is
like $8. So if this is correct, it's pretty good money for those
poor guys down there in Eastman's hidden abode. OTOH, some Chinese
products are made by slave labor, so they say.
Pt
2004-06-04 05:55:24 UTC
Permalink
Post by thomas
Post by Formerly Sideways
Post by GregD/Oasysco
But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.
Ah, the good old labor theory of value. I did not know that you were
of the Marxian persuasion, Greg! My understanding is that Eastman
is owned by a Chinese family. Screwing your own people is just
capitalism at work, as Father Karl taught us. (How do you say
"Mr. Moneybags" in Chinese, I wonder?)
Post by Formerly Sideways
You haven't played an Eastman, you don't really have any idea what
their workers really make, you aren't allowing for the fact that they
may be extremely well-paid by Chinese standards if not by our
standards, you don't know what the production or research and
development cost factors are, etc, etc, etc.
Eastman claims that their workers make acround $200 a month, IIRC,
about twice the average wage in their area. And their rent is
like $8. So if this is correct, it's pretty good money for those
poor guys down there in Eastman's hidden abode. OTOH, some Chinese
products are made by slave labor, so they say.
I remember when I was in Vietnam.
You'd be surprised what you could get for $5.
Maybe you wouldn't....

Pt
Jack Zucker
2004-06-04 10:23:32 UTC
Permalink
Man,

I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word. It's a global economy and it's also a global newsgroup. The world is
not just about America no matter what some of our politicians think....

At some point, China's economy will pick up and the labor prices will go up.
That's just the way things work.
--
Experience a revolutionary way to approach the instrument.
Introducing Sheets of Sound for Guitar
"Let the music govern the way you play guitar instead of the guitar
governing the way you play music!"

Check it out at:
http://www.sheetsofsound.net
Post by Pt
Post by thomas
Post by Formerly Sideways
Post by GregD/Oasysco
But I am glad to see you get incensed over Chinese workers not getting a
fair living wage, which woudl eman that the price of Eastman gutiars are
over-inflated.
Ah, the good old labor theory of value. I did not know that you were
of the Marxian persuasion, Greg! My understanding is that Eastman
is owned by a Chinese family. Screwing your own people is just
capitalism at work, as Father Karl taught us. (How do you say
"Mr. Moneybags" in Chinese, I wonder?)
Post by Formerly Sideways
You haven't played an Eastman, you don't really have any idea what
their workers really make, you aren't allowing for the fact that they
may be extremely well-paid by Chinese standards if not by our
standards, you don't know what the production or research and
development cost factors are, etc, etc, etc.
Eastman claims that their workers make acround $200 a month, IIRC,
about twice the average wage in their area. And their rent is
like $8. So if this is correct, it's pretty good money for those
poor guys down there in Eastman's hidden abode. OTOH, some Chinese
products are made by slave labor, so they say.
I remember when I was in Vietnam.
You'd be surprised what you could get for $5.
Maybe you wouldn't....
Pt
Formerly Sideways
2004-06-04 14:30:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jack Zucker
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word.
Pretty much my point. I was trying to refrain from using the "j" word
(jingoism). I think some people may be listening to too much Toby
Keith.
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 14:57:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by Formerly Sideways
Post by Jack Zucker
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word.
Pretty much my point. I was trying to refrain from using the "j" word
(jingoism). I think some people may be listening to too much Toby
Keith.
I'm thinking more of the "M" word or even the "H" word, but I can accept
"J" and "R" as easily. In fact, A,B,C,D, etc are OK, but my fave has got
to be "Z". That said, I am partial to the "S" word, but like "L" almost
as much.

In any case, I'm not sure what patriotism has to do with it, Jaye. Why
spend $2K for a chinese made guitar when I can buy a chinese-made ibanez
artcore for $300? Are the Eastmans really worth 6 or 7 times the price?

I've heard all those same arguments when I used to promote $500 korean-
made guitars and how this or that was worth 6 times the cost of my korean
made archtop... blah... blah... blah...

Now, I'm hearing that these Chinese made boxes are worth 6-10 times the
price of chinese made Ibanez's or 4 or 5 times Korean made archtops and
that Japanese made Epi elites with solid wood tops at half the price of
an eastman aren't even in the same ballpark.

It'a almost as if China has attained some special place in archtop
luthiery that Korean in it's 20+ years of gutiar making hasn't been able
to do or that Japan with it's 50+ years fo archtop history can't match.

And besides, who are these luthiers? What are there names? We're talking
about a no-name production guitar built by no-name luthiers competing
with Unger and the rest fo the boys who do have a name.

I'm hearing things like John Pisano endorses Eastman, but Larry Coryell
endorsed Cort as did Joe Beck. Joe pass endorsed epiphone and ibanez.
George Benson endorses Ibanez. Kenny Burrel endorses Heritage. Johnny
Smith endorses... ok, he endorses a different maker every 24 months.

Again, maybe Eastmans are the best guitars on earth. Most of you all seem
to think so. And when they come down to $500 as any good chinese product
should, i'll consider them. Let's see where they are in 3 years and how
much they fetch on EBAY at that time.

Greg
Joey Goldstein
2004-06-04 17:20:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
In any case, I'm not sure what patriotism has to do with it, Jaye. Why
spend $2K for a chinese made guitar when I can buy a chinese-made ibanez
artcore for $300? Are the Eastmans really worth 6 or 7 times the price?
Well have you priced the guitars from other companies that have similar
features to the Eastman. You'll find that most of these guitars are at
least 2 times as much $.

When you see a hand carved guitar for $300.00 let me know.
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 17:45:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by GregD/Oasysco
In any case, I'm not sure what patriotism has to do with it, Jaye. Why
spend $2K for a chinese made guitar when I can buy a chinese-made ibanez
artcore for $300? Are the Eastmans really worth 6 or 7 times the price?
Well have you priced the guitars from other companies that have similar
features to the Eastman. You'll find that most of these guitars are at
least 2 times as much $.
That's true, but the question still remains, but now generalized to any
maker - are those $15,000 Benedettos worth 15x more than a production
plywood guitar when it comes to playability and tone or 5x as much as a
lesser known luthier handcarved archtop?

By the same token, is that $3,000 handcarved archtop really worth 10x
more than a Chinese made Ibanez Artcore archtop when it comes to
playability and tone?

I mean, are those expensive guitars really worth it for what you buy a
guitar for - to play it at 5x, 10x, 15x the cost of others? Is there that
much of a difference in tone and feel that makes it worth spending $3,000
over $300? Is there really?
Post by Joey Goldstein
When you see a hand carved guitar for $300.00 let me know.
OK, Gary Stroup on EBAY sells his kiln-dried, solid wood archtops for
about $800. That's 1/3 the cost of a Chinese-made archtop and this guy
lives in the US. How come I don't see folks falling all over themselves
over Gary's work if the issue is simply having a hand-carved archtop?

Greg
Joey Goldstein
2004-06-04 18:00:56 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by GregD/Oasysco
In any case, I'm not sure what patriotism has to do with it, Jaye. Why
spend $2K for a chinese made guitar when I can buy a chinese-made
ibanez
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by GregD/Oasysco
artcore for $300? Are the Eastmans really worth 6 or 7 times the
price?
Post by Joey Goldstein
Well have you priced the guitars from other companies that have similar
features to the Eastman. You'll find that most of these guitars are at
least 2 times as much $.
That's true, but the question still remains, but now generalized to any
maker - are those $15,000 Benedettos worth 15x more than a production
plywood guitar when it comes to playability and tone or 5x as much as a
lesser known luthier handcarved archtop?
No guitar that you're going to actually play is worth $15k IMO.
As a piece of fine art or as an investment those guitars may be worth it though.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
By the same token, is that $3,000 handcarved archtop really worth 10x
more than a Chinese made Ibanez Artcore archtop when it comes to
playability and tone?
Yes, if the $3k guitar has the tone you want to hear.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
I mean, are those expensive guitars really worth it for what you buy a
guitar for - to play it at 5x, 10x, 15x the cost of others? Is there that
much of a difference in tone and feel that makes it worth spending $3,000
over $300? Is there really?
I bought an ES-175 in 1972 for $600 US. I though that was expensive
then. Personally i think the entire archtop market, for quality guitars
(Gibson especially but even companies like Heritage, etc.) is way out of
whack right now. Maybe the competition from peole like eastman will
level the playing field a bit.

I think that reasonably a new ES-175 should cost around $1500.00 and a
new L-5 about $2k. Those would be sane prices IMO.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Joey Goldstein
When you see a hand carved guitar for $300.00 let me know.
OK, Gary Stroup on EBAY sells his kiln-dried, solid wood archtops for
about $800. That's 1/3 the cost of a Chinese-made archtop and this guy
lives in the US. How come I don't see folks falling all over themselves
over Gary's work if the issue is simply having a hand-carved archtop?
Probably because no-one other than you has ever heard of him. If his
guitars are any good I'm sure we will hear about him. Do you have a link?
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 18:27:00 UTC
Permalink
Joey
...snipped...
I bought an ES-175 in 1972 for $600 US. I though that was expensive
then. Personally i think the entire archtop market, for quality
guitars (Gibson especially but even companies like Heritage, etc.) is
way out of whack right now. Maybe the competition from peole like
eastman will level the playing field a bit.
Yes, we can hope for that. I agree, it's totally whack.
I think that reasonably a new ES-175 should cost around $1500.00 and a
new L-5 about $2k. Those would be sane prices IMO.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Joey Goldstein
When you see a hand carved guitar for $300.00 let me know.
OK, Gary Stroup on EBAY sells his kiln-dried, solid wood archtops for
about $800. That's 1/3 the cost of a Chinese-made archtop and this
guy lives in the US. How come I don't see folks falling all over
themselves over Gary's work if the issue is simply having a
hand-carved archtop?
Probably because no-one other than you has ever heard of him. If his
guitars are any good I'm sure we will hear about him. Do you have a link?
I don't know if his stuff is any good. He was into furntiture making and as
of late archtops. I can't find his EBAY auctions thoguh he has had them on
there for months. His ad starts off with "Who is Gray Stroup (sp?)?".

Greg
Joe Finn
2004-06-04 18:54:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
That's true, but the question still remains, but now generalized to any
maker - are those $15,000 Benedettos worth 15x more than a production
plywood guitar when it comes to playability and tone
A carved original Benny can't be compared to production plywood. That's
apples and oranges.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
or 5x as much as a
lesser known luthier handcarved archtop?
That depends on the two individual guitars. Carved top are like snowflakes:
no two are exactly alike. The relative value also depends on what the player
wants to hear. It's another matter entirely from the point of view of the
collector.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
By the same token, is that $3,000 handcarved archtop really worth 10x
more than a Chinese made Ibanez Artcore archtop when it comes to
playability and tone?
I would say so. The artcore is the bottom end of the market. I played a few
of them and they were of very poor quality.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
I mean, are those expensive guitars really worth it for what you buy a
guitar for - to play it at 5x, 10x, 15x the cost of others? Is there that
much of a difference in tone and feel that makes it worth spending $3,000
over $300? Is there really?
To me it all depends on what the player wants to hear. To collectors these
guitars are definitely worth it, but collectors are in the market for
reasons that differ from us players.

One other point about hand made guitars is that it totally depends on the
luthier. Some of these guys are very gifted and make great instruments while
others are well deserving of the obscurity in which they toil. caveat
emptor. ......joe
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
MBR
2004-06-05 04:57:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Finn
no two are exactly alike. The relative value also depends on what the player
wants to hear.
=======================
That's it, exactly. I recently played a boutique archtop that had all
the "right" materials for a quality archtop...carved spruce top, maple
back and sides, ebony fingerboard, all the stuff. But I still prefer
some of my other cheaper, laminated guitars. They just sound right to
me. I guess I like cheap guitars.

-Mark R
Joe Finn
2004-06-05 05:13:31 UTC
Permalink
Post by MBR
That's it, exactly. I recently played a boutique archtop that had all
the "right" materials for a quality archtop...carved spruce top, maple
back and sides, ebony fingerboard, all the stuff. But I still prefer
some of my other cheaper, laminated guitars. They just sound right to
me. I guess I like cheap guitars.
-Mark R
Mark: There is a lot to be said for playing yourself into an instrument. The
way you play has an effect on the wood. In a way this results in the wood
itself conforming to the way the player plays.

I love your guitar. It loves you back ........joe
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 05:46:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Finn
Post by MBR
That's it, exactly. I recently played a boutique archtop that had all
the "right" materials for a quality archtop...carved spruce top,
maple back and sides, ebony fingerboard, all the stuff. But I still
prefer some of my other cheaper, laminated guitars. They just sound
right to me. I guess I like cheap guitars.
-Mark R
Mark: There is a lot to be said for playing yourself into an
instrument. The way you play has an effect on the wood. In a way this
results in the wood itself conforming to the way the player plays.
I love your guitar. It loves you back ........joe
Joe, I'm a little bummed. Do you love my guitar as well as and maybe more
than Mark's ? <g>

Greg
Joe Finn
2004-06-04 19:01:02 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
I'm hearing things like John Pisano endorses Eastman, but Larry Coryell
endorsed Cort as did Joe Beck. Joe pass endorsed epiphone and ibanez.
George Benson endorses Ibanez. Kenny Burrel endorses Heritage. Johnny
Smith endorses... ok, he endorses a different maker every 24 months.
The endorsement game is an important part of the business. The right
endorsement can benefit both the artist and the manufacturer enormously. To
a lot of the parties you mention the publicity and the $$$ are the major
considerations. An endorsement from a Kenny Burrell is worth it's weight in
gold. On some level you have to remember that a guitar is a guitar is a
guitar. Coryell could take a cigar box strung up with rubber bands and make
it sound great. .....joe
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 19:43:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Finn
Post by GregD/Oasysco
I'm hearing things like John Pisano endorses Eastman, but Larry
Coryell endorsed Cort as did Joe Beck. Joe pass endorsed epiphone and
ibanez. George Benson endorses Ibanez. Kenny Burrel endorses
Heritage. Johnny Smith endorses... ok, he endorses a different maker
every 24 months.
The endorsement game is an important part of the business. The right
endorsement can benefit both the artist and the manufacturer
enormously. To a lot of the parties you mention the publicity and the
$$$ are the major considerations. An endorsement from a Kenny Burrell
is worth it's weight in gold. On some level you have to remember that
a guitar is a guitar is a guitar. Coryell could take a cigar box
strung up with rubber bands and make it sound great. .....joe
Agreed. I guess I was alluding that endorsements don't mean as much as we
think they do as far as players being tied exclusively to a manufacturer or
model.

Greg

PS. Very much agreed on the Kenny Burrell endorsement. He is one of my all-
time faves for jazz blues.
Joe Finn
2004-06-05 03:32:28 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Agreed. I guess I was alluding that endorsements don't mean as much as we
think they do as far as players being tied exclusively to a manufacturer or
model.
It sounds like you got it. ;-) ......joe

P.S. My son did a concert in Virginia Beach today. Did you catch it?
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 03:38:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Finn
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Agreed. I guess I was alluding that endorsements don't mean as much
as we think they do as far as players being tied exclusively to a
manufacturer
or
Post by GregD/Oasysco
model.
It sounds like you got it. ;-) ......joe
P.S. My son did a concert in Virginia Beach today. Did you catch it?
No, I didn't know about it. Where did he play? I wish I had known!
Greg
Joe Finn
2004-06-05 04:12:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/oasysco
No, I didn't know about it. Where did he play? I wish I had known!
Greg
It was at Prince something or other High School. I wish I could have been
there myself but at this point I'm the "old man". That means I'm so
unbelievably square and uncool that I'd blow the whole scene!!!
........joe
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 05:45:06 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Finn
Post by GregD/oasysco
No, I didn't know about it. Where did he play? I wish I had known!
Greg
It was at Prince something or other High School. I wish I could have been
there myself but at this point I'm the "old man". That means I'm so
unbelievably square and uncool that I'd blow the whole scene!!!
........joe
Princess Anne Highschool?

Greg
Joe Finn
2004-06-05 15:34:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/oasysco
Princess Anne Highschool?
Greg
That's the one. They did a clinic too. ........joe
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
Steven Rosenberg
2004-06-04 19:59:14 UTC
Permalink
Whether the guitar is made in China, Korea, Japan, Nashville or by the
luthier down the street, when you're paying $2000 for it, you'd better
believe it has to be good. I'll reserve my judgment until I drag my
butt down to California Vintage Guitar and try one. The most troubling
thing in this thread is some writers' contentions that fit and finish
aren't what they could be and that consistency is also lacking. Until
these problems are dealt with, I don't think you'll find a lot of
happy guitarists choosing Eastman over other similar guitars.

On the other hand, the prospect of a fully carved, non-laminated
guitar will be inviting enough to many. When luthiers like Buscarino
offer a "low end" guitar for $3,000, a new Gibson 175 is $3K, and I
don't even know how much the low-end American Archtop model goes for,
you have to know there's room for somebody to get in below that price
point and really clean up. There's something to be said for a bunch of
Chinese guys who know how to make violins and cellos turning their
attention to guitars. With the right training, they could do very
well. And replacing the metal tailpieces with wood shows they're going
in the right direction. Ditto for bringing John Pisano and Steve
Herberman into the fold.

But "all it needs is a good setup" is NOT what I want to hear when
buying something that costs over $1,000. Those instruments shouldn't
leave the factory without the frets properly dressed and with the
bridge and nut ready to go. Even if that works needs to be done in the
U.S. before delivery, everything should be in order.

I don't know what the financial arrangement, but going from an
endorsement of Guild/Benedetto to Eastman is a big deal. All the guys
dumping luthier-made archtops to endorse Hofner is another giant
shift. Whatever you say about it, what's obvious is that Eastman and
Hofner are doing a really good marketing job, and having pros play
your guitar is a necessity if you want to move a lot of wood.
Post by GregD/Oasysco
In any case, I'm not sure what patriotism has to do with it, Jaye. Why
spend $2K for a chinese made guitar when I can buy a chinese-made ibanez
artcore for $300? Are the Eastmans really worth 6 or 7 times the price?
I've heard all those same arguments when I used to promote $500 korean-
made guitars and how this or that was worth 6 times the cost of my korean
made archtop... blah... blah... blah...
Now, I'm hearing that these Chinese made boxes are worth 6-10 times the
price of chinese made Ibanez's or 4 or 5 times Korean made archtops and
that Japanese made Epi elites with solid wood tops at half the price of
an eastman aren't even in the same ballpark.
It'a almost as if China has attained some special place in archtop
luthiery that Korean in it's 20+ years of gutiar making hasn't been able
to do or that Japan with it's 50+ years fo archtop history can't match.
And besides, who are these luthiers? What are there names? We're talking
about a no-name production guitar built by no-name luthiers competing
with Unger and the rest fo the boys who do have a name.
I'm hearing things like John Pisano endorses Eastman, but Larry Coryell
endorsed Cort as did Joe Beck. Joe pass endorsed epiphone and ibanez.
George Benson endorses Ibanez. Kenny Burrel endorses Heritage. Johnny
Smith endorses... ok, he endorses a different maker every 24 months.
Again, maybe Eastmans are the best guitars on earth. Most of you all seem
to think so. And when they come down to $500 as any good chinese product
should, i'll consider them. Let's see where they are in 3 years and how
much they fetch on EBAY at that time.
Greg
Ken Rose
2004-06-04 14:35:03 UTC
Permalink
You are absolutely right, Jack. This has already started to happen in
Chinese cities. There are now quite a few people from Hong Kong looking for
work on the mainland, and the Hong Kong economy has been lifted out of
deflation and recession largely due to mainland tourists coming here and
spending lots of money buying luxury goods. Skip Moy recently did the sound
for a Dior fashion show in Hong Kong that was very high profile and costly,
then they did the same in Beijing. I think people aren't really aware of
just how much things have already changed in China.

Ken Rose
www.cdbaby.com/kenrose
Post by Jack Zucker
Man,
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word. It's a global economy and it's also a global newsgroup. The world is
not just about America no matter what some of our politicians think....
At some point, China's economy will pick up and the labor prices will go up.
That's just the way things work.
--
Experience a revolutionary way to approach the instrument.
Introducing Sheets of Sound for Guitar
"Let the music govern the way you play guitar instead of the guitar
governing the way you play music!"
Mark Kleinhaut
2004-06-04 14:50:57 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ken Rose
You are absolutely right, Jack. This has already started to happen in
Chinese cities. There are now quite a few people from Hong Kong looking for
work on the mainland, and the Hong Kong economy has been lifted out of
deflation and recession largely due to mainland tourists coming here and
spending lots of money buying luxury goods. Skip Moy recently did the sound
for a Dior fashion show in Hong Kong that was very high profile and costly,
then they did the same in Beijing. I think people aren't really aware of
just how much things have already changed in China.
Ken Rose
www.cdbaby.com/kenrose
It's not like it's a secret or anything. There was a very interesting story
aired the other day on NPR http://www.npr.org/features/feature.php?wfId=1920804

I like the line where they say that the Chinese are trading in bicycles for
cars in droves.

***@hotmail.com
http://www.markkleinhaut.com
http://www.invisiblemusicrecords.com


----== Posted via Newsfeed.Com - Unlimited-Uncensored-Secure Usenet News==----
http://www.newsfeed.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! >100,000 Newsgroups
---= 19 East/West-Coast Specialized Servers - Total Privacy via Encryption =---
Pt
2004-06-04 15:00:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ken Rose
You are absolutely right, Jack. This has already started to happen in
Chinese cities. There are now quite a few people from Hong Kong looking for
work on the mainland, and the Hong Kong economy has been lifted out of
deflation and recession largely due to mainland tourists coming here and
spending lots of money buying luxury goods. Skip Moy recently did the sound
for a Dior fashion show in Hong Kong that was very high profile and costly,
then they did the same in Beijing. I think people aren't really aware of
just how much things have already changed in China.
Ken Rose
I am probably wrong but....
My belief has been that our (meaning democracy) most feared enemy is
the Chinese.

I know that the world is changing quickly.
But what is it changing to?

Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 15:16:08 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
Post by Ken Rose
You are absolutely right, Jack. This has already started to happen in
Chinese cities. There are now quite a few people from Hong Kong
looking for work on the mainland, and the Hong Kong economy has been
lifted out of deflation and recession largely due to mainland tourists
coming here and spending lots of money buying luxury goods. Skip Moy
recently did the sound for a Dior fashion show in Hong Kong that was
very high profile and costly, then they did the same in Beijing. I
think people aren't really aware of just how much things have already
changed in China.
Ken Rose
I am probably wrong but....
My belief has been that our (meaning democracy) most feared enemy is
the Chinese.
Let's see... we saved them in WWII; they beat back US forces from the
Yalu river in the 50's during the Korean conflict; they are the world's
manufacturing plant; they put down student led demonstrations with
bullets and tanks; they outnumber us 1.3B to 300M; they have the world's
largest army at 2.5M; they influence NKorea more than they let on.

On the upside, they are allowing more private ownership,but that's not
democracy. It may be the birth pangs of capitalism, but it 'aint
democracy.
Post by Pt
I know that the world is changing quickly.
But what is it changing to?
Good question.

Greg

PS. For the record, I have no problem buying Chinese-made goods, but in
my book they have always been of inferior quality and I expect a deep
discount when buying their goods. Yes, I understand Eastmans are better
than Benedettos per most folks here and like I said, when they hit $500,
I'll consider it. I buy chinese shoes for under $20, so spending $2K on a
Chinese gutiar is against my better judgement.
Post by Pt
Pt
Tone
2004-06-04 15:41:51 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jack Zucker
Man,
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word.
Republican? Ridiculous? Redundant? Rambling?

How about a hint?
Joey Goldstein
2004-06-04 16:54:48 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jack Zucker
Man,
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word. It's a global economy and it's also a global newsgroup. The world is
not just about America no matter what some of our politicians think....
At some point, China's economy will pick up and the labor prices will go up.
That's just the way things work.
China's economy will pick up the way that America wants it to pick up or
it won't pick up at all.
As far as the World economy is concerned right now it *is* all about
America and what America wants. Hopefully, in the long haul, what
America wants will be the most beneficial to the most people. But it
looks like it will probably involve unsustainable growth levels and far
too soon the planet will be stripped of all its resources and polluted
beyond repair. The World is being infected with America's sense of
entitled greed right now.

When we watch those Star Trek NG episodes with the Borg I'll bet most
people think that the Soviets were the analog. But more and more it's
America assimilating everyone and everything. Resistance is futile.

America won't let any other state edge in on its hegemony ever again.
That's what it's about right now, America remaining the strongest power
on the planet *forever*. Of course there are benefits to being
controlled by America and the American system of democracy rather than
some other system like communism. In a democracy the people are allowed
to do what the hell they want most of the time so they don't notice or
complain that their tax dollars are being used by the powers-that-be to
do horrible things trying to make the rest of the world just like them.
It may be that democracy is really the opium of the people.

Thankfully, American style democracy also has a failsafe built in with
freedom of the press and freedom of expression and and it is possible
for the people's conscience to be stirred and the powers-that-be put in
their place. But this requires an alert and moral population.

Flame suit on.
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 17:22:11 UTC
Permalink
Joey,

I don't know about all that political stuff, but one fact remains: the
ES-175 was an American creation.

Greg
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by Jack Zucker
Man,
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the
"R" word. It's a global economy and it's also a global newsgroup. The
world is not just about America no matter what some of our
politicians think....
At some point, China's economy will pick up and the labor prices will
go up. That's just the way things work.
China's economy will pick up the way that America wants it to pick up
or it won't pick up at all.
As far as the World economy is concerned right now it *is* all about
America and what America wants. Hopefully, in the long haul, what
America wants will be the most beneficial to the most people. But it
looks like it will probably involve unsustainable growth levels and
far too soon the planet will be stripped of all its resources and
polluted beyond repair. The World is being infected with America's
sense of entitled greed right now.
When we watch those Star Trek NG episodes with the Borg I'll bet most
people think that the Soviets were the analog. But more and more it's
America assimilating everyone and everything. Resistance is futile.
America won't let any other state edge in on its hegemony ever again.
That's what it's about right now, America remaining the strongest
power on the planet *forever*. Of course there are benefits to being
controlled by America and the American system of democracy rather than
some other system like communism. In a democracy the people are
allowed to do what the hell they want most of the time so they don't
notice or complain that their tax dollars are being used by the
powers-that-be to do horrible things trying to make the rest of the
world just like them. It may be that democracy is really the opium of
the people.
Thankfully, American style democracy also has a failsafe built in with
freedom of the press and freedom of expression and and it is possible
for the people's conscience to be stirred and the powers-that-be put
in their place. But this requires an alert and moral population.
Flame suit on.
Joey Goldstein
2004-06-04 17:37:48 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Joey,
I don't know about all that political stuff, but one fact remains: the
ES-175 was an American creation.
OK.... But what has that got to do with anything?
I haven't read this whole thread. Maybe you're referring to something
else here?
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 18:05:14 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Joey,
I don't know about all that political stuff, but one fact remains: the
ES-175 was an American creation.
OK.... But what has that got to do with anything?
I haven't read this whole thread. Maybe you're referring to something
else here?
Nah, just trying to return us to jazz guitar-related issues instead of
world politics before we turn into AGA.

Greg
Pt
2004-06-04 17:48:14 UTC
Permalink
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 12:54:48 -0400, Joey Goldstein
Post by Joey Goldstein
Thankfully, American style democracy also has a failsafe built in with
freedom of the press and freedom of expression and and it is possible
for the people's conscience to be stirred and the powers-that-be put in
their place. But this requires an alert and moral population.
Flame suit on.
I'm not going to flame you.
You are a Canadian..right?
The reason I ask is because I am interested in what the citizens of
other so called free democracies think of the U.S.

I recall when I was in the army in the 60's.
I was in 9 different countries and even though American citizens died
to protect their freedom they hated Americans.
They think that all Americans are rich and are totally inhumane.

When I got orders for Vietnam I seriously considered citizenship in
Canada.
But I chose to serve my country.

I am totally against what is going on in the Arab countries but I can
honestly say that I don't understand it.
I can't let myself believe that it is all about oil and money.

Pt
Joey Goldstein
2004-06-04 18:18:49 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 12:54:48 -0400, Joey Goldstein
Post by Joey Goldstein
Thankfully, American style democracy also has a failsafe built in with
freedom of the press and freedom of expression and and it is possible
for the people's conscience to be stirred and the powers-that-be put in
their place. But this requires an alert and moral population.
Flame suit on.
I'm not going to flame you.
You are a Canadian..right?
The reason I ask is because I am interested in what the citizens of
other so called free democracies think of the U.S.
I recall when I was in the army in the 60's.
I was in 9 different countries and even though American citizens died
to protect their freedom they hated Americans.
They think that all Americans are rich and are totally inhumane.
When I got orders for Vietnam I seriously considered citizenship in
Canada.
But I chose to serve my country.
I am totally against what is going on in the Arab countries but I can
honestly say that I don't understand it.
I can't let myself believe that it is all about oil and money.
It's all about power and influence. I think that in order for democracy
to work not only do you need to divide church and state but you need to
divide big business and state as well. American style
democracy/capitalism has been controlled by big corporations for at
least a century now. When the corporation's interests coincide with the
people's interests this all works very well. But when their interests
are different problems quickly arise. The environment is the area where
these interests will deviate the most. Corporations need consumers.
Comsumers consume. The environment is finite. Soon there will be nothing
left to consume.

I also think that religion is the biggest danger to man's survival as a
species. I heard a statistic yesterday that 43% of Americans consider
themselves to be born-again Christians. Tom Ridge supposedly has all
sorts of Christian religious stuff going on at the Homeland Security
agency he is running. The Reagan/Bush camp is governed by religous
issues and a large part of their constituency are these born-again Christians.

We've also got fundamentalist Muslims who are convinced that their view
of the cosmos is the only true view and they will kill you if you disagree.
We've also got fundamentalist Jews living right next to them running
Israel who think that God gave them that land when it was really just
the UN.

All 3 of them believe that the world has to explode in a cataclysm so
that the Kingdom Of God can reign afterwards. All 3 of them *need* this
to happen or their whole religious belief system comes tumbling down.
These are the people running the world's most influential states. We are
in deep shit.

Haven't these people heard of the dinosaurs? What do they think all
those fossils are, a trick?
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
Max Leggett
2004-06-04 18:47:42 UTC
Permalink
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 14:18:49 -0400, Joey Goldstein
Post by Joey Goldstein
All 3 of them believe that the world has to explode in a cataclysm so
that the Kingdom Of God can reign afterwards. All 3 of them *need* this
to happen or their whole religious belief system comes tumbling down.
These are the people running the world's most influential states. We are
in deep shit.
The problem is that the people who aren't rabid religionists don't
care enough to get out and vote, while the rabids feel they are
compelled by their god to vote.

Yeats said it much better than I:

Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all convictions, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?






=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
***@hotmail.com is a spam trap
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Jurupari
2004-06-05 17:50:42 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joey Goldstein
I think that in order for democracy
to work not only do you need to divide church and state but you need to
divide big business and state as well.
Oddly, that used to be 'conservative'.

The first premise is based in all our law descended from English common law -
the most basic principle is that you can't serve two masters. That's the real
reason for needing to separate church and state.
Post by Joey Goldstein
American style
democracy/capitalism has been controlled by big corporations for at
least a century now.
more by one party than the other as I'm sure you know. We have some safeguards
with the Sherman Act, and other stuff, but it's not really enough. I've
wondered about the Japanese Zaibatsu concept, and whether that will evolve into
the new kind of state.

What scares me is that corporate agendas have rarely ever displayed much
foresight, so any consequenses of their actions that's five years down the
road is off the radar.

It also scares me that during the Reagan years and again now, business ethics
have regressed to Victorian standards here.
Post by Joey Goldstein
The environment is finite. Soon there will be nothing
left to consume.
True, and moreover, unless something happens to our trade laws, the whole thing
could collapse even before then.

Our trade deficits and outsourcing proclivities have already displaced security
and patriotism with corporate profit.

Also we outsource to third world polluters who who aren't accountable for
waste, and therefore can let their services go for fractions of what it would
cost to be globally responsible.

We outsource the very infrastructure we'd need to defend ourselves in a global
war to the countries we'd need to defend ourselves against, and are paying
possible future enemy soldiers to do work seized from american vets and others.


Moreover, China, for example is flooding our market with scrap steel after
we've exported our manufacturing, and is also knocking off our designs and
other intellectual property, a lose lose lose situation.

It's kind of like trying to make a career out of donating blood, and expecting
annual raises in productivity. And, your banker is Vlad Tepes...

Soon there will be nothing
Post by Joey Goldstein
left to consume.
true.
Post by Joey Goldstein
I also think that religion is the biggest danger to man's survival as a
species
I've been afraid to say that out loud myself, but when I hear it, for thousands
of reasons, I'd have to concur. You would have enjoyed hearing Bill Maher his
last time on Larry King on the same topic.
Post by Joey Goldstein
The Reagan/Bush camp is governed by religous
issues and a large part of their constituency are these born-again Christians.
These people's views are a considerable threat to constitutional government and
our concept of democracy.

As a political body, they do not favor two party government, and it is
necessary for them to be both socialists and totalitarians in order to
perpetrate their agenda.

It would die in a truly free state as fundamentalist morality can only be
enforced via huge governments, massive behavior modification programs and
Khrushchev-like secret police and informer networks. And gulags for the
infidel, of course.

I read the rest of your post too, and would like to interject something that
may be a 22nd century thought:

At this time, it may be a short time before human beings can actually become
discorporate - the technology is starting to line up now with nanotech machines
- imagine molecular computers that document every synapse, can change dna and
create new complex molecules by simultaneous reactions of nanomachines
controlled by nanocomputers and store what they need in many easily replicated
loci.

In any case, the conventional threats of physical destruction might not apply
if we had options as to states of existence that didn't depend on physical
bodies, or a single one, at least.

But the same technology in the hands of one miscreant could destroy everything
material.
Post by Joey Goldstein
We are
in deep shit.
Real deep, and sort of funny colored too.

I'll close with an allegorical thought - if the ship of state is guided by
'moral compass', and its True North is representational government, continual
course corrections to EITHER the left or right will have the same result:

Pretty soon you're headed South...at that point left meets right.

Clif Kuplen
William C.
2004-06-05 18:29:24 UTC
Permalink
Enjoyed your take, Clif.
And I do agree with your assessments.
It is probable at this point the U.S. will be severely, ahem, "trimmed
back." The bridge has been crossed, and the country is doing its damndest to
burn it.
Because of that, I have doubts that nanotechnology will play that big a deal
in the lives of Americans, post-nuclear, "incidents." It will be down to
survival, all the while with inane news programs covering it...
But, one can't tell..... For sure, nanotechnology will be abused. Just to
what extent, here in the good 'ol U.S.A., as in near future...

"The President's Analyst," was a ride, with corporate desires for control
coupled with an early take on nanotechnology... a hoot from the 60s.

Now that IT jobs have been going overseas, there are and will be cries of
indignation.... that should have been raised long ago when it was the
manufacturing guy that went from a living wage to a living hovel, crammed
into it with folks he wouldn't have been caught dead with, let alone alive,
30 years ago.

Killing prisoners as object lessons to others that are in a pipeline slated
for torture, humiliation.... This has been covered in Nuremburg, with regard
to personal responsibility, from the line to up the line... all the way to
the top.

A kid with his arms blown off for an oil grab.... Don't see the folks with
faces blown off, forever to grope.

Personal responsibility for what is going on, every tax payer, and every
person that is out of work and can't pay taxes if they wanted to.....

I'm not quiet, not rolling over.
It is disgusting to see so many devote so much energy to what amounts to
brainless, soulless diversions, when so much is at stake.

When drug cops with helmets patterned after Nazi Germany and goose stepping
boots started breaking into homes and brutalizing innocents for the sake of
a, "war on drugs," that should have been the call to arms right then and
there. Speaking of which, I remember some administration official, when
pegged on the question of eliminating drug crops with the, "victory, " in
Afghanistan... and declining to commit to such, as it was a matter of
economics and survival for the people who lived there....

Sickening, absurd. And the silent sheeple. The loud mouthed, brain pan is
kinda' tiny patriots.... "True Patriots," would have been raising hell a
long time ago with the selling out of livelihoods and security.

This thing is gonna' get it unless there is a real upheaval.. something most
folks don't have the appetite for...... Right now there is a huge sign on
the American Backside.... all those containers coming in.... that doesn't
say, "kick me." It says, "nuke me."

If anybody doesn't like what I've said, I couldn't care less... and won't
bother responding to flames.
Maybe one or two frogs formerly content to while away with diversions while
being slowly boiled to death will say, Hell, this water is sure getting
hot.....
Post by Jurupari
Post by Joey Goldstein
I think that in order for democracy
to work not only do you need to divide church and state but you need to
divide big business and state as well.
Oddly, that used to be 'conservative'.
The first premise is based in all our law descended from English common law -
the most basic principle is that you can't serve two masters. That's the real
reason for needing to separate church and state.
Post by Joey Goldstein
American style
democracy/capitalism has been controlled by big corporations for at
least a century now.
more by one party than the other as I'm sure you know. We have some safeguards
with the Sherman Act, and other stuff, but it's not really enough. I've
wondered about the Japanese Zaibatsu concept, and whether that will evolve into
the new kind of state.
What scares me is that corporate agendas have rarely ever displayed much
foresight, so any consequenses of their actions that's five years down the
road is off the radar.
It also scares me that during the Reagan years and again now, business ethics
have regressed to Victorian standards here.
Post by Joey Goldstein
The environment is finite. Soon there will be nothing
left to consume.
True, and moreover, unless something happens to our trade laws, the whole thing
could collapse even before then.
Our trade deficits and outsourcing proclivities have already displaced security
and patriotism with corporate profit.
Also we outsource to third world polluters who who aren't accountable for
waste, and therefore can let their services go for fractions of what it would
cost to be globally responsible.
We outsource the very infrastructure we'd need to defend ourselves in a global
war to the countries we'd need to defend ourselves against, and are paying
possible future enemy soldiers to do work seized from american vets and others.
Moreover, China, for example is flooding our market with scrap steel after
we've exported our manufacturing, and is also knocking off our designs and
other intellectual property, a lose lose lose situation.
It's kind of like trying to make a career out of donating blood, and expecting
annual raises in productivity. And, your banker is Vlad Tepes...
Soon there will be nothing
Post by Joey Goldstein
left to consume.
true.
Post by Joey Goldstein
I also think that religion is the biggest danger to man's survival as a
species
I've been afraid to say that out loud myself, but when I hear it, for thousands
of reasons, I'd have to concur. You would have enjoyed hearing Bill Maher his
last time on Larry King on the same topic.
Post by Joey Goldstein
The Reagan/Bush camp is governed by religous
issues and a large part of their constituency are these born-again Christians.
These people's views are a considerable threat to constitutional government and
our concept of democracy.
As a political body, they do not favor two party government, and it is
necessary for them to be both socialists and totalitarians in order to
perpetrate their agenda.
It would die in a truly free state as fundamentalist morality can only be
enforced via huge governments, massive behavior modification programs and
Khrushchev-like secret police and informer networks. And gulags for the
infidel, of course.
I read the rest of your post too, and would like to interject something that
At this time, it may be a short time before human beings can actually become
discorporate - the technology is starting to line up now with nanotech machines
- imagine molecular computers that document every synapse, can change dna and
create new complex molecules by simultaneous reactions of nanomachines
controlled by nanocomputers and store what they need in many easily replicated
loci.
In any case, the conventional threats of physical destruction might not apply
if we had options as to states of existence that didn't depend on physical
bodies, or a single one, at least.
But the same technology in the hands of one miscreant could destroy everything
material.
Post by Joey Goldstein
We are
in deep shit.
Real deep, and sort of funny colored too.
I'll close with an allegorical thought - if the ship of state is guided by
'moral compass', and its True North is representational government, continual
Pretty soon you're headed South...at that point left meets right.
Clif Kuplen
Pt
2004-06-05 19:22:35 UTC
Permalink
Bill,
Your key word (in my opinion) was
"Sheeple".
That's what this country has turned in to.
No longer people who care or speak their own minds.
But Sheeple who follow the crowd.
I HATE THAT!!!

Pt
William C.
2004-06-05 19:34:26 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
Bill,
Your key word (in my opinion) was
"Sheeple".
That's what this country has turned in to.
No longer people who care or speak their own minds.
But Sheeple who follow the crowd.
I HATE THAT!!!
Pt
There have always been sheeple.
Most are raised in flocks, their movements/freedoms restricted, to render a
continual supply of wool, to be sheared at regular intervals... Of course
they think, insofar as they do, they are free within the confines of the
fences they inhabit.
Some are eaten.
Pt
2004-06-05 18:53:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jurupari
Pretty soon you're headed South...at that point left meets right.
Clif Kuplen
We only know what we read, hear or see on TV.
I wonder what is really going on?

Pt
Joey Goldstein
2004-06-05 20:32:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
Post by Jurupari
Pretty soon you're headed South...at that point left meets right.
Clif Kuplen
We only know what we read, hear or see on TV.
I wonder what is really going on?
Pt
Try turning off the TV. Read some Noam Chomsky for starters. His books
are still available, for now.
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
Max Leggett
2004-06-05 20:58:48 UTC
Permalink
On Sat, 05 Jun 2004 16:32:30 -0400, Joey Goldstein
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by Pt
Post by Jurupari
Pretty soon you're headed South...at that point left meets right.
Clif Kuplen
We only know what we read, hear or see on TV.
I wonder what is really going on?
Pt
Try turning off the TV. Read some Noam Chomsky for starters. His books
are still available, for now.
Read? Read??? You seriously expect people to make an effort to see
past the spin????? Get a grip!!!!!!


:-)







=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
***@hotmail.com is a spam trap
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
William C.
2004-06-05 00:52:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
I can't let myself believe that it is all about oil and money.
You know the old one, Pat.... fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice,
shame on....
Post by Pt
Pt
William C.
2004-06-05 00:43:44 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joey Goldstein
Post by Jack Zucker
Man,
I have to say that some components of this discussion border on the "R"
word. It's a global economy and it's also a global newsgroup. The world is
not just about America no matter what some of our politicians think....
At some point, China's economy will pick up and the labor prices will go up.
That's just the way things work.
China's economy will pick up the way that America wants it to pick up or
it won't pick up at all.
As far as the World economy is concerned right now it *is* all about
America and what America wants. Hopefully, in the long haul, what
America wants will be the most beneficial to the most people. But it
looks like it will probably involve unsustainable growth levels and far
too soon the planet will be stripped of all its resources and polluted
beyond repair. The World is being infected with America's sense of
entitled greed right now.
When we watch those Star Trek NG episodes with the Borg I'll bet most
people think that the Soviets were the analog. But more and more it's
America assimilating everyone and everything. Resistance is futile.
America won't let any other state edge in on its hegemony ever again.
That's what it's about right now, America remaining the strongest power
on the planet *forever*. Of course there are benefits to being
controlled by America and the American system of democracy rather than
some other system like communism. In a democracy the people are allowed
to do what the hell they want most of the time so they don't notice or
complain that their tax dollars are being used by the powers-that-be to
do horrible things trying to make the rest of the world just like them.
It may be that democracy is really the opium of the people.
Thankfully, American style democracy also has a failsafe built in with
freedom of the press and freedom of expression and and it is possible
for the people's conscience to be stirred and the powers-that-be put in
their place. But this requires an alert and moral population.
Flame suit on.
--
Joey Goldstein
http://www.joeygoldstein.com
joegold AT sympatico DOT ca
Ah Joey... it is good to hear you say all this....

ten, twenty nukes in containers by former friends will put the powers that
be in their place...
At a time when people should be raising hell with what is going on, they
will most likely wind up catching it....

Just waiting to turn the tube on to hear/witness the non-stop news coverage
of the first mushroom cloud. Think there's a, "health crisis," now?....
Haven't seen anything yet.

And democracy.... that's a semantic mine field, a flag waved, a banner born,
by people who think they think.

It is Ovuh..... just waiting for the other shoe to drop.
Pt
2004-06-03 18:29:11 UTC
Permalink
Post by Kevin Van Sant
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having played
one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made guitar, when
you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for their efforts.
What kind of shoes do you wear?
Nikusho Qun's

Pt
Max Leggett
2004-06-03 18:02:50 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 17:45:05 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having played
one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made guitar, when
you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for their efforts.
I'm not saying that Eastman guitars are the greatest guitars on the
planet... they may well be.
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore guitar
that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I personally still
have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese, Korean, or Mexican
guitar.
Then you'd better go to the barricades and smash the system.



=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
***@hotmail.com is a spam trap
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Pt
2004-06-03 18:28:19 UTC
Permalink
Are the underpaid Chinese workers who make guitars making less in
wages than those who make dress shoes?
Are they underpaid by Chinese wage standards or by ours?
I would think that the poor underpaid Chinese workers are making a
good buck as far as their economomic standards go.

Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-03 20:09:40 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
Are the underpaid Chinese workers who make guitars making less in
wages than those who make dress shoes?
Are they underpaid by Chinese wage standards or by ours?
I would think that the poor underpaid Chinese workers are making a
good buck as far as their economomic standards go.
Pt
I hope they are, but I'd rather buy direct from the factory in this
particular case.

Greg
Pt
2004-06-03 21:15:15 UTC
Permalink
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 20:09:40 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Pt
Are the underpaid Chinese workers who make guitars making less in
wages than those who make dress shoes?
Are they underpaid by Chinese wage standards or by ours?
I would think that the poor underpaid Chinese workers are making a
good buck as far as their economomic standards go.
Pt
I hope they are, but I'd rather buy direct from the factory in this
particular case.
Greg
The factory is in Peking.

Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 12:15:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
On Thu, 03 Jun 2004 20:09:40 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Pt
Are the underpaid Chinese workers who make guitars making less in
wages than those who make dress shoes?
Are they underpaid by Chinese wage standards or by ours?
I would think that the poor underpaid Chinese workers are making a
good buck as far as their economomic standards go.
Pt
I hope they are, but I'd rather buy direct from the factory in this
particular case.
Greg
The factory is in Peking.
Road trip!

Greg
Post by Pt
Pt
dunlop212
2004-06-04 01:03:05 UTC
Permalink
According to the site, the workers are highly paid craftsmen by
chinese standards. Quite a bit of the finish work takes place in
Maryland. The link is in the other thread. It's OK, I think, to be
down on chinese imports in general. I kind of feel that way about the
french. But unless they are lying on the web site (which I take it you
can't be bothered to read), there is no exploitation or sweat shop
involved here.

I'm not an economist or a politician. Intelligent people take a number
of positions on trade policy, and those debates have no place here.
But I have to say that you are being unreasonably obdurate on the
difference between a CNC plywood guitar assembled in a sweat shop and
a hand carved guitar made by luthiers, no matter what country they
live in.
Pt
2004-06-03 21:26:27 UTC
Permalink
I mean, if you buy an american made car, there are compnents from
abroad inside (maybe you have a german made injection or an english
hydraulic cylinder or a japanese microchip in the dashboard somewhere)
- it still says "made with pride in the USA" (by underpaid illegal
immigrants :o)

Pt
Modern Vintage
2004-06-04 02:27:54 UTC
Permalink
My experience with Eastman guitars so far is that they have extremely
bad customer service! Been trying to get 2 since January and they
always say they are being shipped but never show up, the guy who runs
the guitar dept is a total flake!!
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 17:52:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by Modern Vintage
My experience with Eastman guitars so far is that they have extremely
bad customer service! Been trying to get 2 since January and they
always say they are being shipped but never show up, the guy who runs
the guitar dept is a total flake!!
You must be one of those American bigots! How dare you question Eastman and
our Chinese comrades, I mean, friends. Remember, you aren't paying for
service, you are paying for a solid wood archtop. Service is an American
dream; the rest of the world could give a hoot. So shuddap, sit down, and
wait... and I don't care if you wait til next year, young man... you are
waiting on the best archtop ever made by human hands. Why, I hear they
deliver $5,000 tone for $2,000! Then again, I heard an Epi Joe Pass deliver
$20,000 tone for $600 a few years back <g>

Greg
Greger Hoel
2004-06-04 18:08:19 UTC
Permalink
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 17:52:59 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Service is an American dream; the rest of the world could give a hoot.
Right. Now, if just the rest of us could have the USA's stellar
business ethics...
--
______________________________________________

What's up Chuck?


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 18:17:48 UTC
Permalink
Post by Greger Hoel
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 17:52:59 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Service is an American dream; the rest of the world could give a hoot.
Right. Now, if just the rest of us could have the USA's stellar
business ethics...
Exactly my point, Greger! And I appreciate your support! You've got the
right attitude. Yes, the world would be a better place; perhaps a little
less populated, but better.

Greg

PS. I was being full of feces, I mean, facetious in the post from which you
took that comment.
Nate Lamy
2004-06-04 00:23:02 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having played
one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made guitar, when
you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for their efforts.
I'm not saying that Eastman guitars are the greatest guitars on the
planet... they may well be.
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore guitar
that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I personally still
have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese, Korean, or Mexican
guitar.
Greg
Are your comments regarding China/Korea/Mexico related to quality or
to labour practises?

Focusing on Eastman quality, it's an interesting question that really
addresses a lot of personal values regarding "guitar cool." I suggest
you do two things that are REALLY easy to do:
1 - find out about the history of Eastman - you will be pleasantly
surprised, I suspect.
2 - find a recent (3d Generation) Eastman and play it for awhile - you
will be pleasantly surprised, I suspect.

I have tracked the company and periodically checked out their guitars
since they started making archtops. IMO, their Gen 1 instruments were
problematic. Gen 2 instruments were a lot better, but were
inconsistent in a variety of important ways. Their Gen 3 stuff is
excellent. I played several of their guitars for several hours at the
last NAMM show (I was working at the close-by Hofner booth), and have
subsequently played several of their guitars at the 12th Fret up here
in Toronto.

I do note that you do not mention Japan on your list of countries of
origin that trouble you. Not reading anything into your omission but
rather reflecting on personal experience, I can remember when the idea
of buying a Japanese guitar (let alone an archtop) was laughable. Not
anymore - I regularly argue for the merits of carved-top, hand-built
European Hofners against the MORE EXPENSIVE pressed-top archtops
coming out of Japan under the D'Aquisto/D'Angelico name. Great
guitars, but pricey to me for what one gets.

I believe that Eastman is quite different from most of the other
manufacturers in China at this point. Their work is fine, their wood
is fine, their finishes are fine and their warranty is fine. Their
cases suck, but that's an easy fix. They are building a nice brand and
giving players very little reason to ever have to "trade up". Power to
them.

As far as the issues of low labour rates (and low cost-of-living,
living standards and so forth) and global trade are considered, it's
complex and certainly worthy of discussion, but I just wanted to focus
on the instruments themselves for a bit.

- Nate
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 17:55:32 UTC
Permalink
Nate,
Post by Nate Lamy
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing
for their efforts. I'm not saying that Eastman guitars are the
greatest guitars on the planet... they may well be.
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore
guitar that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I
personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese,
Korean, or Mexican guitar.
Greg
Are your comments regarding China/Korea/Mexico related to quality or
to labour practises?
My comments are based solely on paying $2,000 for a Chinese-made guitar.
I'm as ready to do that as I am to pay $2,000 for a Korean-made gutiar or
Indonesian or Indian. That's my only beef.

Greg

PS. I did read their history,but my beef is with the price tag.
Post by Nate Lamy
Focusing on Eastman quality, it's an interesting question that really
addresses a lot of personal values regarding "guitar cool." I suggest
1 - find out about the history of Eastman - you will be pleasantly
surprised, I suspect.
2 - find a recent (3d Generation) Eastman and play it for awhile - you
will be pleasantly surprised, I suspect.
I have tracked the company and periodically checked out their guitars
since they started making archtops. IMO, their Gen 1 instruments were
problematic. Gen 2 instruments were a lot better, but were
inconsistent in a variety of important ways. Their Gen 3 stuff is
excellent. I played several of their guitars for several hours at the
last NAMM show (I was working at the close-by Hofner booth), and have
subsequently played several of their guitars at the 12th Fret up here
in Toronto.
I do note that you do not mention Japan on your list of countries of
origin that trouble you. Not reading anything into your omission but
rather reflecting on personal experience, I can remember when the idea
of buying a Japanese guitar (let alone an archtop) was laughable. Not
anymore - I regularly argue for the merits of carved-top, hand-built
European Hofners against the MORE EXPENSIVE pressed-top archtops
coming out of Japan under the D'Aquisto/D'Angelico name. Great
guitars, but pricey to me for what one gets.
I believe that Eastman is quite different from most of the other
manufacturers in China at this point. Their work is fine, their wood
is fine, their finishes are fine and their warranty is fine. Their
cases suck, but that's an easy fix. They are building a nice brand and
giving players very little reason to ever have to "trade up". Power to
them.
As far as the issues of low labour rates (and low cost-of-living,
living standards and so forth) and global trade are considered, it's
complex and certainly worthy of discussion, but I just wanted to focus
on the instruments themselves for a bit.
- Nate
Pt
2004-06-04 03:00:45 UTC
Permalink
In American money it probably costs a couple hundred dollars to make
the guitar and import it.
Someone is making a lot of money.

Pt
Max Leggett
2004-06-04 03:10:33 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
In American money it probably costs a couple hundred dollars to make
the guitar and import it.
Someone is making a lot of money.
Have you any evidence to that effect? Can you produce any figures? You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?



=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
***@hotmail.com is a spam trap
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Joe Finn
2004-06-04 03:38:32 UTC
Permalink
Post by Max Leggett
You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
That's just it.

Lots of good quality instruments are coming out of Asian replication
facilities these days.

Great instruments are still handmade one at a time by craftsmen who have
dedicated their lives to the endeavor. Greatness requires the hand of time.

And time is money. ....joe
--
Visit me on the web www.joefinn.net




-----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =-----
http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
-----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =-----
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 17:48:48 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Finn
Post by Max Leggett
You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
That's just it.
Lots of good quality instruments are coming out of Asian replication
facilities these days.
No argument there. Remember, at one time, I was the king of cheap, offshore
archtops :)-

Greg
Post by Joe Finn
Great instruments are still handmade one at a time by craftsmen who
have dedicated their lives to the endeavor. Greatness requires the
hand of time.
And time is money. ....joe
Pt
2004-06-04 05:05:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by Max Leggett
Have you any evidence to that effect? Can you produce any figures? You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
Here is a rave review from Harmony Central.

Price Paid: US $2,304

Purchased from: N/A

Features: N/A
Hello


There have been many exciting opinions rendered regarding
Eastman guitars.
I would like to share my Eastman experience.
Having heard so much positive feedback regarding Eastman Uptown
guitars, I purchased an 810CE from Guitars n Jazz in Summit, NJ in
July 03. Distance prevented me from sampling guitars first hand, so I
bought sight unseen. The guitar arrived and I was as excited as anyone
to open the box and see the extraordinarily beautiful guitar inside
the “funky” black case which I eventually replaced..
I started spending time with the instrument and was impressed by its
great sound and tone. Great acoustic qualities right off the bat. Over
the following week, I noticed very rough edges on all the frets. I
realized that the frets had not been dressed properly. One could
actually run their fingers down the fret board and catch skin on the
fret edges. I contacted the dealer and he authorized the repair which
was paid for by him.
Soon after plugging the guitar in to play electric, I noticed this
very slight static noise that was like a very low pitched buzz. I
posted this on the Eastman news group under the heading of Static On
My Uptown. After many suggestions and troubleshooting on my part, it
was determined that the guitar was missing a ground wire. Both Gordon
Roberts of Eastman and Guitars N Jazz authorized me to get this fixed.
It was at this time that I also started to get buzzes at certain fret
locations. I took the guitar to Superior Guitar in Philadelphia and
during the process of installing the ground wire and checking the
frets we found that most of the frets were loose enough to come up by
putting your fingernail under them and pushing up. The Luthier
assessed that the fret slots had been cut slightly larger than
necessary. He also pointed out a bent tailpiece plate that was not
seating properly! At this point I contacted the dealer, who contacted
Eastman, and the guitar was shipped back to Eastman for inspection. I
paid Superior Guitar and used UPS shipping with insurance to send the
guitar to Eastman. Eastman decided they would replace the guitar.
After one misfire of sending me an 805CE I very happily received
another 810CE which I was very excited to finally have in my
possession, more than a month after having given the guitar up for
repair. I opened the case to inspect the guitar, but was shocked to
find rough edges on the frets of this guitar as well. This time not as
severe as the original, but I could not settle for this. I contacted
Eastman and they agreed to refund my original purchase price,
“excluding” the ground wire repair and UPS shipping, all of which had
been authorized by Eastman and was paid for out of pocket by me. That
was unfair as all I wanted was an excellent Eastman which was their
promise. It is true that Eastman has very good customer service. They
were very accommodating. However, Eastman needs to look at their
quality control issues. Obviously, my original guitar #292 should not
have left Estman as is. I only express what I have experienced first
hand. I have owned many fine guitars over the years and have never had
problems of this nature. I only asked the same of my Eastman 810CE,
something they couldnÂ’t deliver me.


Be Well,
John

Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 12:23:30 UTC
Permalink
Pt,

Ha-ha... missing a ground wire... that's rich. Well, Ok so maybe one
slipped by their diligent quality assurance :)-

Greg
Post by Pt
Post by Max Leggett
Have you any evidence to that effect? Can you produce any figures? You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
Here is a rave review from Harmony Central.
Price Paid: US $2,304
Purchased from: N/A
Features: N/A
Hello
There have been many exciting opinions rendered regarding
Eastman guitars.
I would like to share my Eastman experience.
Having heard so much positive feedback regarding Eastman Uptown
guitars, I purchased an 810CE from Guitars n Jazz in Summit, NJ in
July 03. Distance prevented me from sampling guitars first hand, so I
bought sight unseen. The guitar arrived and I was as excited as anyone
to open the box and see the extraordinarily beautiful guitar inside
the “funky” black case which I eventually replaced..
I started spending time with the instrument and was impressed by its
great sound and tone. Great acoustic qualities right off the bat. Over
the following week, I noticed very rough edges on all the frets. I
realized that the frets had not been dressed properly. One could
actually run their fingers down the fret board and catch skin on the
fret edges. I contacted the dealer and he authorized the repair which
was paid for by him.
Soon after plugging the guitar in to play electric, I noticed this
very slight static noise that was like a very low pitched buzz. I
posted this on the Eastman news group under the heading of Static On
My Uptown. After many suggestions and troubleshooting on my part, it
was determined that the guitar was missing a ground wire. Both Gordon
Roberts of Eastman and Guitars N Jazz authorized me to get this fixed.
It was at this time that I also started to get buzzes at certain fret
locations. I took the guitar to Superior Guitar in Philadelphia and
during the process of installing the ground wire and checking the
frets we found that most of the frets were loose enough to come up by
putting your fingernail under them and pushing up. The Luthier
assessed that the fret slots had been cut slightly larger than
necessary. He also pointed out a bent tailpiece plate that was not
seating properly! At this point I contacted the dealer, who contacted
Eastman, and the guitar was shipped back to Eastman for inspection. I
paid Superior Guitar and used UPS shipping with insurance to send the
guitar to Eastman. Eastman decided they would replace the guitar.
After one misfire of sending me an 805CE I very happily received
another 810CE which I was very excited to finally have in my
possession, more than a month after having given the guitar up for
repair. I opened the case to inspect the guitar, but was shocked to
find rough edges on the frets of this guitar as well. This time not as
severe as the original, but I could not settle for this. I contacted
Eastman and they agreed to refund my original purchase price,
“excluding” the ground wire repair and UPS shipping, all of which had
been authorized by Eastman and was paid for out of pocket by me. That
was unfair as all I wanted was an excellent Eastman which was their
promise. It is true that Eastman has very good customer service. They
were very accommodating. However, Eastman needs to look at their
quality control issues. Obviously, my original guitar #292 should not
have left Estman as is. I only express what I have experienced first
hand. I have owned many fine guitars over the years and have never had
problems of this nature. I only asked the same of my Eastman 810CE,
something they couldnÂ’t deliver me.
Be Well,
John
Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 12:21:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by Max Leggett
Post by Pt
In American money it probably costs a couple hundred dollars to make
the guitar and import it.
Someone is making a lot of money.
Have you any evidence to that effect? Can you produce any figures? You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
No way! Those Chinese luthiers with centuries of expertise, who have
grown up generation after generation making fine arched top instruments
are not likely to work for anything less than $0.10/hour. Ergo, there is
no way you can cheaply make a fine, carved archtop instrument that gets
rave reivews from not only everybody woh has played one, but most of
those who have not!

I'll bet... I'll just bet that the importer is losing millions on those
guitars because Chinese workers are so expensive! In fact, that's why
they chose the Chinese market because the cost of living is so high and
workers demand high wages and good working conditions!

Greg
Post by Max Leggett
=======================================
Jailhouse Baby Parker
the world's finest living Max Leggett-style guitarist
m le gg e tt doing business with sprint in CAnada
=======================================
Pt
2004-06-04 12:43:28 UTC
Permalink
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 12:21:15 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Max Leggett
Post by Pt
In American money it probably costs a couple hundred dollars to make
the guitar and import it.
Someone is making a lot of money.
Have you any evidence to that effect? Can you produce any figures? You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
No way! Those Chinese luthiers with centuries of expertise, who have
grown up generation after generation making fine arched top instruments
are not likely to work for anything less than $0.10/hour. Ergo, there is
no way you can cheaply make a fine, carved archtop instrument that gets
rave reivews from not only everybody woh has played one, but most of
those who have not!
I'll bet... I'll just bet that the importer is losing millions on those
guitars because Chinese workers are so expensive! In fact, that's why
they chose the Chinese market because the cost of living is so high and
workers demand high wages and good working conditions!
Greg
I saw a good deal on matching Chinese made Flame Suits.
2 for the price of 1.
38, 986.02 piasters.

Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 17:47:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
On Fri, 04 Jun 2004 12:21:15 GMT, "GregD/Oasysco"
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Post by Max Leggett
Post by Pt
In American money it probably costs a couple hundred dollars to make
the guitar and import it.
Someone is making a lot of money.
Have you any evidence to that effect? Can you produce any figures? You
seriously think a hand carved archtop, that gets rave reviews from
everyone who's ever played one, can be made for a couple of hundred
dollars?
No way! Those Chinese luthiers with centuries of expertise, who have
grown up generation after generation making fine arched top instruments
are not likely to work for anything less than $0.10/hour. Ergo, there is
no way you can cheaply make a fine, carved archtop instrument that gets
rave reivews from not only everybody woh has played one, but most of
those who have not!
I'll bet... I'll just bet that the importer is losing millions on those
guitars because Chinese workers are so expensive! In fact, that's why
they chose the Chinese market because the cost of living is so high and
workers demand high wages and good working conditions!
Greg
I saw a good deal on matching Chinese made Flame Suits.
2 for the price of 1.
38, 986.02 piasters.
Pat, I don't expect they will last through these flames, but if you pick
up a set, send one of them, please <g>

Greg
Post by Pt
Pt
GregD/Oasysco
2004-06-04 18:03:27 UTC
Permalink
How did my original post that follows get twisted into (1) me having a
patriotic bent for the US and against the Chinese, (2) me believing
Eastmans are junk, (3) me being against all offshore/asian guitars... all I
ever said was "I personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for
a Chinese, Korean, or Mexican guitar".

Greg

PS. Anybody know what thew warranty is for eastman gutiars. I don't see it
on their website. I assume that since they are world-class, they have a
lifetime warranty. Either that or they are so well made, you don't need no
stinkin' warranty. Anybody know?
Post by GregD/Oasysco
My take is... well, I have not take on these gutiars never having
played one. My issue is plunking down $2,000 USD for a Chinese made
guitar, when you know the Chinese craftsman make little to nothing for
their efforts.
I'm not saying that Eastman guitars are the greatest guitars on the
planet... they may well be.
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore
guitar that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I
personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese,
Korean, or Mexican guitar.
Greg
Formerly Sideways
2004-06-05 03:36:04 UTC
Permalink
"GregD/Oasysco" <***@oasyscoATcoxDOTnet.none> wrote .> How did my
original post that follows get twisted into (1) me having a
Post by GregD/Oasysco
patriotic bent for the US and against the Chinese, (2) me believing
Eastmans are junk, (3) me being against all offshore/asian guitars... all I
ever said was "I personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for
a Chinese, Korean, or Mexican guitar".
Greg
Yep that's it, Greg, we twisted your well-thought out posts into
something you never intended. I guess we should walk a mile in your
Chinese dress shoes before we question why you would have a problem
with spending more than $600 for a guitar made in China.
DB
2004-06-05 09:39:58 UTC
Permalink
I seriously considered buying an Eastman guitar. I talked to an
Eastman dealer who said to me "The first thing you will have to do is
change the pickup because these come with crappy chinese pickups". He
also told me that they originally had problems with them and that he
doesn't have to send back as many as he used to.

Then I considered the resale value and decided to spend the extra
bucks and get a used Gibson L5 ... mainly because I always wanted one.
It cost me $3,500 USD and is just like new and the tone is classic.

Over 30 years ago I played an L5 that was for sale (barely used)... It
was only $400 and I couldn't afford it. What's that guitar worth now?
At the time, the musicians union's monthly newspaper had DeAngelico
guitars for sale for $1,200 and DeAquisto's for $700 and numerous
Stradivarious violins for around $20,000. I'd say they were good
investments. At the time that was "out of this world" bucks.

I figured that if I'm gonna lay down big bucks for a guitar (I'm a
musician for a living and $3,500 is a lot of gigs), then I'm gonna get
what I want. Now every time I practice, perform or just look at it
sitting on the stage during break, I feel good about it.

Whatever you do, buy a guitar that really turns you on... Spend as
much as you can afford or just save for the one you really want.
There's nothing in the world like it. It's second to a true loving
relationship. I hate to sound corny but I never thought in my wildest
dreams that a material object could bring me so much satisfaction. I
now feel like those "Harley owners"... Thrilled.

About the chinese worker thing. I believe a Chinese person that makes
20 cents an hour will do a finer job than a young American working for
minimum wage. Most Chinese are Buddist and their philosophy is "Thank
you God for getting me through this day"... I played in Japan and saw
a factory worker bring home 2 beers to his wife and she cried with
joy.

db
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore
guitar that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I
personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese,
Korean, or Mexican guitar.
Greg
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 14:29:18 UTC
Permalink
Post by DB
About the chinese worker thing. I believe a Chinese person that makes
20 cents an hour will do a finer job than a young American working for
minimum wage.
You may be right. So, yer saying 20 cents an hour?
Post by DB
Most Chinese are Buddist and their philosophy is "Thank
you God for getting me through this day"... I played in Japan and saw
a factory worker bring home 2 beers to his wife and she cried with
joy.
I've brought cases of brew home before and never got so much as a squeeze!
That's what I need - my wife to be brainwashed into thinking that 2 beers
is the greatest gift on earth. Hmmm, wonder what she'd do for a six-pack?
<g>

Greg
Post by DB
db
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore
guitar that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I
personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese,
Korean, or Mexican guitar.
Greg
Modern Vintage
2004-06-05 17:54:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by DB
I seriously considered buying an Eastman guitar. I talked to an
Eastman dealer who said to me "The first thing you will have to do is
change the pickup because these come with crappy chinese pickups". He
also told me that they originally had problems with them and that he
doesn't have to send back as many as he used to.
Then I considered the resale value and decided to spend the extra
bucks and get a used Gibson L5 ... mainly because I always wanted one.
It cost me $3,500 USD and is just like new and the tone is classic.
Over 30 years ago I played an L5 that was for sale (barely used)... It
was only $400 and I couldn't afford it. What's that guitar worth now?
At the time, the musicians union's monthly newspaper had DeAngelico
guitars for sale for $1,200 and DeAquisto's for $700 and numerous
Stradivarious violins for around $20,000. I'd say they were good
investments. At the time that was "out of this world" bucks.
I figured that if I'm gonna lay down big bucks for a guitar (I'm a
musician for a living and $3,500 is a lot of gigs), then I'm gonna get
what I want. Now every time I practice, perform or just look at it
sitting on the stage during break, I feel good about it.
Whatever you do, buy a guitar that really turns you on... Spend as
much as you can afford or just save for the one you really want.
There's nothing in the world like it. It's second to a true loving
relationship. I hate to sound corny but I never thought in my wildest
dreams that a material object could bring me so much satisfaction. I
now feel like those "Harley owners"... Thrilled.
About the chinese worker thing. I believe a Chinese person that makes
20 cents an hour will do a finer job than a young American working for
minimum wage. Most Chinese are Buddist and their philosophy is "Thank
you God for getting me through this day"... I played in Japan and saw
a factory worker bring home 2 beers to his wife and she cried with
joy.
db
Post by GregD/Oasysco
Could I be talked into spending $2,000 for an exceptional off-shore
guitar that is equivalent to a $5,000 US product? Maybe, but I
personally still have a problem chunking down 2 grand for a Chinese,
Korean, or Mexican guitar.
Greg
The funny thing is that the US dealer buys them for 1/2 of retail and
makes about $900 on every guitar!
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
2004-06-05 17:59:52 UTC
Permalink
Post by Modern Vintage
The funny thing is that the US dealer buys them for 1/2 of retail and
makes about $900 on every guitar!
Well, what do folks think is a fair retail market for a guitar? I'm
talking about a retailer that services you right, sets up the instrument
right, handles problems, etc.

Steve
--
Mark & Steven Bornfeld DDS
http://www.dentaltwins.com
Brooklyn, NY
Pt
2004-06-04 18:10:59 UTC
Permalink
It is rare that a thread in this group goes political.
I think that is good.
It allows the people of the world who are interested in jazz guitar
read and write messages without discrimination.

But every now and then I feel that it is acceptable to veer of the
track.
I know very little about politics and I care even less.
But I do want to know what others here think of what is going on in
the world.
Possibly because of the fact that I was in the most hated war in
American history.
I don't want to see that happen again.
It is an insult to those who devote their lives to serve our country.

Pt
L. Fiorillo
2004-06-05 13:46:48 UTC
Permalink
Why should all guitars made in China be the same price regardless of
materials, quality or labor hours? I've never played an Eastman, but I'd
say yes, a handcarved instrument that takes more than 6 or 7 times longer to
build than an assembly line plywood guitar almost untouched by human hands
should most definitely be 6 or 7 times the price.

Why spend $40K on a D'Aquisto when I can get an ES175 for $3K? They're both
made in the USA, so they should be the same price, right? It's apples and
oranges.

Anyway, my advice would be to play the guitar you are going to buy. Each
instrument (mass produced and handmade) are different, and you'll find the
one that speaks to you.

<In any case, I'm not sure what patriotism has to do with it, Jaye. Why
spend $2K for a chinese made guitar when I can buy a chinese-made ibanez
artcore for $300? Are the Eastmans really worth 6 or 7 times the price?

I've heard all those same arguments when I used to promote $500 korean-
made guitars and how this or that was worth 6 times the cost of my korean
made archtop... blah... blah... blah...

Now, I'm hearing that these Chinese made boxes are worth 6-10 times the
price of chinese made Ibanez's or 4 or 5 times Korean made archtops and
that Japanese made Epi elites with solid wood tops at half the price of
an eastman aren't even in the same ballpark.

It'a almost as if China has attained some special place in archtop
luthiery that Korean in it's 20+ years of gutiar making hasn't been able
to do or that Japan with it's 50+ years fo archtop history can't match.

And besides, who are these luthiers? What are there names? We're talking
about a no-name production guitar built by no-name luthiers competing
with Unger and the rest fo the boys who do have a name.

I'm hearing things like John Pisano endorses Eastman, but Larry Coryell
endorsed Cort as did Joe Beck. Joe pass endorsed epiphone and ibanez.
George Benson endorses Ibanez. Kenny Burrel endorses Heritage. Johnny
Smith endorses... ok, he endorses a different maker every 24 months.

Again, maybe Eastmans are the best guitars on earth. Most of you all seem
to think so. And when they come down to $500 as any good chinese product
should, i'll consider them. Let's see where they are in 3 years and how
much they fetch on EBAY at that time.

Greg>
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 14:31:42 UTC
Permalink
Post by L. Fiorillo
Why should all guitars made in China be the same price regardless of
materials, quality or labor hours? I've never played an Eastman, but
I'd say yes, a handcarved instrument that takes more than 6 or 7 times
longer to build than an assembly line plywood guitar almost untouched
by human hands should most definitely be 6 or 7 times the price.
Why spend $40K on a D'Aquisto when I can get an ES175 for $3K?
They're both made in the USA, so they should be the same price, right?
It's apples and oranges.
Anyway, my advice would be to play the guitar you are going to buy.
Each instrument (mass produced and handmade) are different, and you'll
find the one that speaks to you.
I'm driving this argument on emotion and you're not helping. You make too
much sense, so stop!

Greg
Pt
2004-06-05 15:02:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/oasysco
I'm driving this argument on emotion and you're not helping. You make too
much sense, so stop!
Greg
What would make sense to me would be to know just what is going on.
You are not buying these guitars from Chinese manufacturers.
You are buying them from an American company and an American dealer.
How much do they make the price up?
What it cost if you purchased it in China?
Who actually makes them (company)?
What would it cost if you bought direct from the factory? (mailorder).

Do you really believe that the major guitar makers would allow Chinese
made guitars outsell theirs?
I'm sure a lot of money is being made on these guitars and I can bet
that that money is not going to the luthiers and manufacturers.

What we are seeing with these guitars is something that was made for
Americans.
And as everyone knows all Americans are rich.
Thus we rich dudes can pay top buck.

Before I would jump in to dropping 2 grand for a Chinese guitar I
would want more information.

Pt
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 20:02:43 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
Post by GregD/oasysco
I'm driving this argument on emotion and you're not helping. You make
too much sense, so stop!
Greg
What would make sense to me would be to know just what is going on.
You are not buying these guitars from Chinese manufacturers.
You are buying them from an American company and an American dealer.
How much do they make the price up?
What it cost if you purchased it in China?
If i knew that, I'd probably be much sicker about it than I am now.
Better not to know.
Post by Pt
Who actually makes them (company)?
Some Samick-like Chinese company.
Post by Pt
What would it cost if you bought direct from the factory? (mailorder).
Do you really believe that the major guitar makers would allow Chinese
made guitars outsell theirs?
I honestly think that if this model succeeds, you'll see other comapnies
moving some of their production over there. Ibanez already does it with
their Artcore line.
Post by Pt
I'm sure a lot of money is being made on these guitars and I can bet
that that money is not going to the luthiers and manufacturers.
My point as well.
Post by Pt
What we are seeing with these guitars is something that was made for
Americans.
I'd generalize it - being made for the West.
Post by Pt
And as everyone knows all Americans are rich.
Thus we rich dudes can pay top buck.
Yup. but that doesn't seem faze anybody here.
Post by Pt
Before I would jump in to dropping 2 grand for a Chinese guitar I
would want more information.
I still wouldn't drop $2k for a Chinese guitar.

Greg
Post by Pt
Pt
L. Fiorillo
2004-06-05 16:55:31 UTC
Permalink
I really think you'd be nuts for buying anything but a 175. If you end up
picking up an Eastman or a Hofner, the GAS would return in no time! I know
that you pay way too much for having Gibson on the headstock, but when you
find that magical 175 or L5, there is no other instrument like it.
Post by GregD/oasysco
Post by L. Fiorillo
Why should all guitars made in China be the same price regardless of
materials, quality or labor hours? I've never played an Eastman, but
I'd say yes, a handcarved instrument that takes more than 6 or 7 times
longer to build than an assembly line plywood guitar almost untouched
by human hands should most definitely be 6 or 7 times the price.
Why spend $40K on a D'Aquisto when I can get an ES175 for $3K?
They're both made in the USA, so they should be the same price, right?
It's apples and oranges.
Anyway, my advice would be to play the guitar you are going to buy.
Each instrument (mass produced and handmade) are different, and you'll
find the one that speaks to you.
I'm driving this argument on emotion and you're not helping. You make too
much sense, so stop!
Greg
GregD/oasysco
2004-06-05 20:04:04 UTC
Permalink
Post by L. Fiorillo
I really think you'd be nuts for buying anything but a 175. If you
end up picking up an Eastman or a Hofner, the GAS would return in no
time! I know that you pay way too much for having Gibson on the
headstock, but when you find that magical 175 or L5, there is no other
instrument like it.
Depending on what happens, that is my likely course of action, but then
again I can't justify it right now as my ES-135LE setup for jazz does
what I need for the little bit of jazz I play.

Greg
Post by L. Fiorillo
Post by GregD/oasysco
Post by L. Fiorillo
Why should all guitars made in China be the same price regardless
of materials, quality or labor hours? I've never played an
Eastman, but I'd say yes, a handcarved instrument that takes more
than 6 or 7 times longer to build than an assembly line plywood
guitar almost untouched by human hands should most definitely be 6
or 7 times the price.
Why spend $40K on a D'Aquisto when I can get an ES175 for $3K?
They're both made in the USA, so they should be the same price, right?
It's apples and oranges.
Anyway, my advice would be to play the guitar you are going to buy.
Each instrument (mass produced and handmade) are different, and
you'll find the one that speaks to you.
I'm driving this argument on emotion and you're not helping. You make
too much sense, so stop!
Greg
William C.
2004-06-05 20:31:53 UTC
Permalink
Post by GregD/oasysco
Post by L. Fiorillo
I really think you'd be nuts for buying anything but a 175. If you
end up picking up an Eastman or a Hofner, the GAS would return in no
time! I know that you pay way too much for having Gibson on the
headstock, but when you find that magical 175 or L5, there is no other
instrument like it.
Depending on what happens, that is my likely course of action, but then
again I can't justify it right now as my ES-135LE setup for jazz does
what I need for the little bit of jazz I play.
Greg
Greg,

I've been playing jazz for myself on a mexistrat with flats.... the lack of
aesthetic likeability in some regards has been made up for in spades by
actual..... Music.

Yes, with little to nothing else to inspire me, it has come down to...
simply playing. If ever I go back to playing for a living, or just for the
heck of it in front of an audience, I'll be ahead of the curve that would
have been had all the other guitars been around.....
Pt
2004-06-05 19:05:15 UTC
Permalink
Just possibly, but I doubt it, China producing high quality
instruments at low prices for American consumption might get companies
like Gibson and Gretsch to lower their prices.

Pt
Pt
2004-06-05 19:28:47 UTC
Permalink
A political comment.

As many of you know I served in Vietnam.
Not because I wanted to but because I was drafted and I felt that it
was my duty to serve my country.
I wasn't there a month before I knew that it was a phony political war
that we weren't supposed to win.
We were sent there for only one reason.
To die!
We were not allowed to fire back when fired upon unless we called in
first.
But most of us did not have a field phone.
I flew as a door gunner on helicopters.
We were not allowed to fire back even if we took a hit.
We could only fire on designated targets where were mostly herds of
oxen and rice paddies.
We were all issued an M-16 in 1967 to replace the indestructible M-14
that we were originally issued.
Most of the M-16's would jam and not fire if they were even damp and
here we were in a monsoon.
Thousands of American kids died because of that.
I could go on and on.
But the people at home, the parents, brothers and sisters watched the
war on TV.
They saw the American soldiers killing the enemy, blowing up
everything in sight and of course high body counts...which were all
lies.
The American public saw a proud soldier fighting for his country and
democracy.
BAH!
35 years later.....
The real truth has not come out and it never will.

So here we are again watching a war on TV and reading the papers.
Don't you wonder what is really going on over there and why?

I do.

Pt
William C.
2004-06-05 19:42:05 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
We were all issued an M-16 in 1967 to replace the indestructible M-14
that we were originally issued.
Most of the M-16's would jam and not fire if they were even damp and
here we were in a monsoon.
Thousands of American kids died because of that.
I could go on and on.
The SKS and the AK47. Buried in pits with tarps thrown over them. Dug up
months later. Boom boom boom, take a licking keep a ticking. There have been
calls for decades to make the AK47 the standard U.S. arm, and by folks
within the military.
And the Makarov... a prize of tunnel rats when they found one down there....
smaller, double action, more reliable, preferred over standard issue 45 for
the job.

In arming for what comes up the road, and living in the country where you
have to fend for yourself anyway.... I've settled for SKS (a tad more
accurate over a longer distance) and Makarovs. Reliability.
Post by Pt
Pt
Pt
2004-06-05 19:51:06 UTC
Permalink
On Sat, 5 Jun 2004 14:42:05 -0500, "William C."
Post by William C.
Post by Pt
We were all issued an M-16 in 1967 to replace the indestructible M-14
that we were originally issued.
Most of the M-16's would jam and not fire if they were even damp and
here we were in a monsoon.
Thousands of American kids died because of that.
I could go on and on.
The SKS and the AK47. Buried in pits with tarps thrown over them. Dug up
months later. Boom boom boom, take a licking keep a ticking. There have been
calls for decades to make the AK47 the standard U.S. arm, and by folks
within the military.
And the Makarov... a prize of tunnel rats when they found one down there....
smaller, double action, more reliable, preferred over standard issue 45 for
the job.
In arming for what comes up the road, and living in the country where you
have to fend for yourself anyway.... I've settled for SKS (a tad more
accurate over a longer distance) and Makarovs. Reliability.
Post by Pt
Pt
Give me a UZI...all plastic!!

Pt
William C.
2004-06-05 20:58:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by Pt
On Sat, 5 Jun 2004 14:42:05 -0500, "William C."
Post by William C.
Post by Pt
We were all issued an M-16 in 1967 to replace the indestructible M-14
that we were originally issued.
Most of the M-16's would jam and not fire if they were even damp and
here we were in a monsoon.
Thousands of American kids died because of that.
I could go on and on.
The SKS and the AK47. Buried in pits with tarps thrown over them. Dug up
months later. Boom boom boom, take a licking keep a ticking. There have been
calls for decades to make the AK47 the standard U.S. arm, and by folks
within the military.
And the Makarov... a prize of tunnel rats when they found one down there....
smaller, double action, more reliable, preferred over standard issue 45 for
the job.
In arming for what comes up the road, and living in the country where you
have to fend for yourself anyway.... I've settled for SKS (a tad more
accurate over a longer distance) and Makarovs. Reliability.
Post by Pt
Pt
Give me a UZI...all plastic!!
I guess you Could bag a deer with the uzi....
Speaking of which, I've seen 50 feet from the back door.
Let the animals live, thrive, multiply in security and friendship. Might
have to eat them one day.
Post by Pt
Pt
Pt
2004-06-05 19:31:43 UTC
Permalink
A political comment.

As many of you know I served in Vietnam.
Not because I wanted to but because I was drafted and I felt that it
was my duty to serve my country.
I wasn't there a month before I knew that it was a phony political war
that we weren't supposed to win.
We were sent there for only one reason.
To die!
We were not allowed to fire back when fired upon unless we called in
first.
But most of us did not have a field phone.
I flew as a door gunner on helicopters.
We were not allowed to fire back even if we took a hit.
We could only fire on designated targets where were mostly herds of
oxen and rice paddies.
We were all issued an M-16 in 1967 to replace the indestructible M-14
that we were originally issued.
Most of the M-16's would jam and not fire if they were even damp and
here we were in a monsoon.
Thousands of American kids died because of that.
I could go on and on.
But the people at home, the parents, brothers and sisters watched the
war on TV.
They saw the American soldiers killing the enemy, blowing up
everything in sight and of course high body counts...which were all
lies.
The American public saw a proud soldier fighting for his country and
democracy.
BAH!
35 years later.....
The real truth has not come out and it never will.

So here we are again watching a war on TV and reading the papers.
Don't you wonder what is really going on over there and why?

I do.

Pt
Loading...