Discussion:
Jack Petersen Mastering the Keys book
(too old to reply)
Frankdiggs
2019-09-25 22:42:35 UTC
Permalink
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or experience with this book. Thanks
Gerry
2019-09-26 00:32:27 UTC
Permalink
Post by Frankdiggs
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight
shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering
the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the
description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or
experience with this book. Thanks
What would you need to know other than the description? Just a
"good/bad" rating?

I hadn't noted it until you mentioned it, and I'm someone who loves
digging through methods and folios. Funny it should come up now: Every
few years I grab a lot of written material and read music for a few
weeks. It puts my head and my playing into a different place. So I
may well get this volume to see what's up. There's not *hardly* enough
instructional etudes and written material for the non-classical guitar.
Frankdiggs
2019-09-26 01:23:31 UTC
Permalink
I was just wondering if anyone had position suggestions. That may sound like an basic question but I was looking for a way to approach the etudes. In that regard the book gives no suggestions. I’m sure many would say just play them, but I figured someone on here might have some insight into approaching them.
Gerry
2019-09-26 06:01:50 UTC
Permalink
Post by Frankdiggs
I was just wondering if anyone had position suggestions. That may sound
like an basic question but I was looking for a way to approach the
etudes. In that regard the book gives no suggestions. I’m sure many
would say just play them, but I figured someone on here might have some
insight into approaching them.
I'll get a copy and see what I can see.

I'm surprised a book about sight-reading for the guitar doesn't address
positions or shifts. But perhaps that's part of the process. Years
ago my guitar teacher told me to "follow the triads". If I encountered
an arpeggio that was easily played in a triad location I should make
that my position. For instance: Bb (below middle C), D and F. This
could be played in a few places, but he would select one in which all
notes would get their own string.

Many such etudes have very few logical places to play them. They have
a low G or F over here, and an E above the staff. So you have to plot
a route between those and frequently the fingering will make itself
known by playing phrases in multiple places--only one really works
comfortably.

That *is* part of the basic difficulties of reading for guitar, but I'm
surprised to think Peterson doesn't address it directly.

I notice that Amazon has hardbound copy for $912.87.

-- Gerry
Frankdiggs
2019-09-27 00:24:47 UTC
Permalink
Thanks for the insight regarding the locations of the triads. That is definitely a new approach for me. I also expected more direction when I ordered the book because his book Chords Galore contains pretty clear instruction on chord inversions. In this book, the entire introduction is two sentences that basically says reading music is not a mystery and this book is to help eliminate the fear. The only other instructions are brief before each etude but only mentions the keys. I guess you are correct and that possibly discovering the positions on your own is his intended process. That being said “Beginning Guitar” is also in the title so one would think positions would be mentioned.
Tony DeCaprio
2019-09-27 14:59:06 UTC
Permalink
Contact me: ***@yahoo.com

I will help you.

Tony DeCaprio
Gerry
2019-09-27 22:11:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by Frankdiggs
I was just wondering if anyone had position suggestions. That may sound
like an basic question but I was looking for a way to approach the
etudes. In that regard the book gives no suggestions. I’m sure many
would say just play them, but I figured someone on here might have some
insight into approaching them.
Play it all at first position. If that presents no problems for you,
play it in 4th or 5th position. When that's not problematic, 7th or
8th.

If you note there are chords positions with fret markers. Just
glancing at it, it would make sense to play them at the general locatio
of the chord.

I recommend Klosés Daily Exercises for Clarinet as soon as you're able.
funkifized
2019-09-27 03:51:12 UTC
Permalink
Post by Gerry
Post by Frankdiggs
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight
shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering
the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the
description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or
experience with this book. Thanks
What would you need to know other than the description? Just a
"good/bad" rating?
I hadn't noted it until you mentioned it, and I'm someone who loves
digging through methods and folios. Funny it should come up now: Every
few years I grab a lot of written material and read music for a few
weeks. It puts my head and my playing into a different place. So I
may well get this volume to see what's up. There's not *hardly* enough
instructional etudes and written material for the non-classical guitar.
I feel like Leavitt has it covered: https://amzn.to/2nCuaig https://amzn.to/2lxUYjd
https://amzn.to/2m9ii75
Gerry
2019-09-27 06:26:09 UTC
Permalink
Post by funkifized
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight>
shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering>
the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the> >
description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or> >
experience with this book. Thanks
What would you need to know other than the description? Just a>
"good/bad" rating?
I hadn't noted it until you mentioned it, and I'm someone who loves
digging through methods and folios. Funny it should come up now: Every
few years I grab a lot of written material and read music for a few
weeks. It puts my head and my playing into a different place. So I
may well get this volume to see what's up. There's not *hardly* enough
instructional etudes and written material for the non-classical guitar.
I feel like Leavitt has it covered: https://amzn.to/2nCuaig
https://amzn.to/2lxUYjd
https://amzn.to/2m9ii75
I'm a fan of Leavitt; any Leavitt, all Leavitt. But reading is about
reading, so I like to read Klosé clarinet etudes and trombone etudes as
well. Though I admit reading bass clef remains an additional trial.
funkifized
2019-09-27 03:10:50 UTC
Permalink
Post by Frankdiggs
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or experience with this book. Thanks
https://books.google.com/books/about/Beginning_Guitar.html?id=WmMKVISpn7wC&printsec=frontcover&source=kp_read_button#v=onepage&q&f=false
Gerry
2019-09-27 22:09:33 UTC
Permalink
Post by Frankdiggs
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight
shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering
the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the
description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or
experience with this book. Thanks
I just got this book via Amazon, and didn't notice the "beginning"
element in the title till I opened it. This almost at the "Oh,
Susanna" level reading challenges. Though it does move faster than the
Oh, Susanna books do. There are lots of courtesy flats and sharps in
parenthese to remind you that an accidental is no longer applicable
after a bar line has interceded. I don't even think that's helpful.
You need to remember that an accidental is applied to the entire bar
after citation, and then goes back to it's key-indicated status.
Gerry
2019-09-27 22:16:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by Gerry
Post by Frankdiggs
Hello I’m new to this forum. I’m really enjoying a lot of the insight
shared on here. I just came across this book Jack Petersen Mastering
the Keys. I can’t find anything about this book besides the
description. I figured I ask on here if anyone has any insight or
experience with this book. Thanks
I just got this book via Amazon, and didn't notice the "beginning"
element in the title till I opened it. This almost at the "Oh,
Susanna" level reading challenges. Though it does move faster than the
Oh, Susanna books do. There are lots of courtesy flats and sharps in
parenthese to remind you that an accidental is no longer applicable
after a bar line has interceded. I don't even think that's helpful.
You need to remember that an accidental is applied to the entire bar
after citation, and then goes back to it's key-indicated status.
I love Amazon, I'm returning it today.
Frankdiggs
2019-09-28 00:52:16 UTC
Permalink
Thanks, your advice on starting in the first position and then moving to 4th or 5th and 7th or 8th really helps. That gives the guidelines I was looking for thanks again!
Loading...