Discussion:
Recommend a group that only talks about music
(too old to reply)
Brian Oates
2019-04-14 22:55:28 UTC
Permalink
Is there a surviving discussion group that talks about music and not politics? I want to participate in music discussions without any veering off into political debates. For me music is an escape from those discussions, my main emphasis is jazz guitar performing and repertoire so TDPRI and GDP type forums are too much about soldering parts and equipment decisions for this.
Gerry
2019-04-14 23:30:31 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brian Oates
Is there a surviving discussion group that talks about music and not
politics? I want to participate in music discussions without any
veering off into political debates. For me music is an escape from
those discussions, my main emphasis is jazz guitar performing and
repertoire so TDPRI and GDP type forums are too much about soldering
parts and equipment decisions for this.
Welcome to *all* discussion, post-Fox. There's always the various
Facebook guitar groups, but I find there's not much real discussion
there. It's just link-sharing: Look at this, look at that. Arguably
most of the "discussion groups" had some carping because people only
talked too much about guitar-collecting and string gauges.

This group actually discussed music, guitar, jazz, and if you were
willing to set up kill-files for psychos and fascist trolls, you could
actually engage. But trolls pretty much beat down the will of the crew
and they dissipated.

Oh well.

Here's one person's view of "great" blogs:

https://www.theguitarjournal.com/10-great-guitar-blogs-worth-follow/

Some consider jazzguitar.be the last remaining enclave.

I've recently been shuffling hundreds of files, snatches of writing
stored on my harddrive, in DevonThink, Scrivener and MacJournal where I
wrote longer posts later posted here, as well as email to other
players, and ruminations I never intended to pass on. Dang: A lot of
chatter! Back when I could regularly discuss music, I was constantly
encouraged to actually play more; I was just thinking about so much of
the time. Now it's dissipated a great deal. I guess that's life.
Defiant
2019-04-15 04:29:00 UTC
Permalink
Post by Gerry
This group actually discussed music, guitar, jazz, and if you were
willing to set up kill-files for psychos and fascist trolls,
If he killfiles psychos and fascist trolls, how will he see any
of YOUR posts?
clevelandjazz
2019-05-30 01:59:11 UTC
Permalink
that's simply not true about the facebook groups. At least not in modern jazz guitar. Facebook is friendlier about posting links so of course there are better and more live links to music but afterall, music is about more than just talking. But there's plenty of talk in that group and unless the wild west (here), there is actual participation by members paul bollenback, vic juris, peter bernstein, peter mazza, kevin clark, bobby broom and many other great players.
c***@gmail.com
2019-06-11 12:49:53 UTC
Permalink
Thanks for the link Clevelandjazz...a lot of the guys that were here before this group got hijacked are now on that FB page. It's decent...but please don't tell 'anybody'!!
Lord Valve
2019-06-11 13:33:38 UTC
Permalink
Post by c***@gmail.com
Thanks for the link Clevelandjazz...a lot of the guys that were here before this group got hijacked are now on that FB page. It's decent...but please don't tell 'anybody'!!
Yeah, I mean...wouldn't want anyone to float an
extra account (or two or three) and roll in under
an assumed nom de plume. Shit, he might start
telling the truth about some pretentious assholes
he made acquaintance with on RMMGJ. Know what I
mean? Watch your neighbors. Loose Lips Sink Ships.
And remember Why We Fight.

Lord Valve, ThD
Organist (fuck you)

T R U M P 2 0 2 0 - M A G A - 1 7 7 6 / 1 8 6 1
Lord Valve
2019-06-11 19:42:05 UTC
Permalink
Post by Lord Valve
Post by c***@gmail.com
Thanks for the link Clevelandjazz...a lot of the guys that were here before this group got hijacked are now on that FB page. It's decent...but please don't tell 'anybody'!!
Yeah, I mean...wouldn't want anyone to float an
extra account (or two or three) and roll in under
an assumed nom de plume. Shit, he might start
telling the truth about some pretentious assholes
he made acquaintance with on RMMGJ. Know what I
mean? Watch your neighbors. Loose Lips Sink Ships.
And remember Why We Fight.
Lord Valve, ThD
Organist (fuck you)
T R U M P 2 0 2 0 - M A G A - 1 7 7 6 / 1 8 6 1
Don't worry, assholes - I never join moderated
forums. Your playground is safe - from me, at
least. But I'm not the only one you turds have
pissed on over the years; some of those people
have long memories...

Know what I mean, Hoss?

s***@gmail.com
2019-04-16 09:00:49 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brian Oates
Is there a surviving discussion group that talks about music and not politics? I want to participate in music discussions without any veering off into political debates. For me music is an escape from those discussions, my main emphasis is jazz guitar performing and repertoire so TDPRI and GDP type forums are too much about soldering parts and equipment decisions for this.
voices of sanity should not ring in these halls anymore=
let the dead eat the dead- here
Lord Valve
2019-06-11 13:37:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by s***@gmail.com
Post by Brian Oates
Is there a surviving discussion group that talks about music and not politics? I want to participate in music discussions without any veering off into political debates. For me music is an escape from those discussions, my main emphasis is jazz guitar performing and repertoire so TDPRI and GDP type forums are too much about soldering parts and equipment decisions for this.
voices of sanity should not ring in these halls anymore=
let the dead eat the dead- here
Imagine a total whacktard/mental case nattering on
about "sanity." Oh, wait...that just happened, did
it not?

Carry on wanking; stiff upper lip, wot?


Lord Valve, ThD
Organist (fuck you)

T R U M P 2 0 2 0 - M A G A - 1 7 7 6 / 1 8 6 1
clevelandjazz
2019-05-30 01:01:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Brian Oates
Is there a surviving discussion group that talks about music and not politics? I want to participate in music discussions without any veering off into political debates. For me music is an escape from those discussions, my main emphasis is jazz guitar performing and repertoire so TDPRI and GDP type forums are too much about soldering parts and equipment decisions for this.
look up "modern jazz guitar" on facebook.
Loading...